| Category | WithumSmith+Brown PC | Wipfli LLP |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,986 | 1,986 |
| Employees | 2,500 | 3,000 |
| Headquarters | Princeton, NJ | Eau Claire, WI |
| Website | withum.com/ | wipfli.com/ |
| Latest Audit Statistics | 932 plans audited · $355.2B AUM | 817 plans audited · $68.3B AUM |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare | 401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare |
| Accreditations | AICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member | AICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC |
| Published Pricing | — | — |
| Locations | Princeton, NJ, Princeton, NJ | Eau Claire, WI, Eau Claire, WI |
Comparison Details
Withum vs Wipfli: comparing employee benefit plan auditors Choosing an ERISA auditor is about more than a firm name—your decision impacts audit readiness, timelines, request lists, and how smoothly your Form 5500 filing process runs. Both WithumSmith+Brown PC (Withum) and Wipfli LLP (Wipfli) are large, established accounting firms (each founded in 1986 ) that support a broad mix of retirement and benefit plan audits. Below is a practical comparison for sponsors evaluating Withum vs Wipfli . At-a-glance: firm size, footprint, and plan coverage Headquarters: Withum—Princeton, NJ; Wipfli—Eau Claire, WI Employees: Withum ~2,500; Wipfli ~3,000 Plans supported: Both support 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit , ESOP , and health & welfare plans Because both firms cover the same major plan types, the differentiators typically come down to audit scale, industry alignment, geographic servicing model, and how each team handles complex plan features (eligibility, payroll integration, allocations, forfeitures, loans, SOC reports, and ESOP/DB valuation topics). 401(k) audit volume and audited assets (2024) Audit volume can be a useful proxy for how frequently a firm encounters common operational issues and how standardized their audit process may be. Withum 401(k) audits (2024): 932 plans audited; $355.2B in audited 401(k) assets (AUM) Wipfli 401(k) audits (2024): 817 plans audited; $68.3B in audited 401(k) assets (AUM) On the data provided, Withum shows higher 401(k) audit volume and substantially higher audited 401(k) assets for 2024. If your plan sponsor values a firm that regularly audits larger pools of 401(k) assets (or a higher number of plans), Withum may stand out in this snapshot. Industry focus and advisory orientation Wipfli positions itself as a consulting-and-accounting firm with clearly stated industry concentrations (e.g., financial services, technology, construction, real estate, manufacturing, healthcare, and nonprofits). This can be helpful if you want an auditor familiar with your sector’s payroll patterns, workforce eligibility profiles, and benefit administration realities. Withum describes itself as a Top 25 U.S. professional services firm delivering advisory, tax, and audit services “local-to-global.” If you’re a multi-entity sponsor or anticipate cross-functional support beyond the audit (tax, transactions, broader assurance coordination), Withum’s positioning may align well. How to choose between Withum and Wipfli Choose Withum if you want an auditor with higher reported 401(k) audit volume and audited assets in the latest year provided, or you expect complexity tied to scale. Choose Wipfli if you value a consulting-forward approach and prefer a firm that emphasizes industry specialization across many middle-market sectors. Either firm can fit if your priority is broad plan-type coverage (401(k)/403(b)/DB/ESOP/H&W) and you plan to evaluate based on engagement team credentials, timeline commitments, and audit request-list efficiency. Questions to ask on the proposal call Who will be the day-to-day manager and reviewer, and what is their benefit plan audit specialization? What is your expected timeline from PBC request to draft financials and final opinion? How do you coordinate with our recordkeeper/TPA and handle SOC 1 report reliance? How do you price the audit (participant count, complexity, locations, ESOP/DB valuation needs)? Bottom line: Withum vs Wipfli is a comparison between two large, capable benefit plan auditors. Use the 2024 audit volume and AUM figures as a starting point, then validate fit through team experience, process, and responsiveness during the proposal stage.