| Category | Voya Financial | TIAA |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | — | 1,918 |
| Employees | 9,000 | — |
| Headquarters | New York City, NY | New York, NY |
| Website | voya.com/ | tiaa.org/ |
| Latest Client Statistics | 65,135 clients · $729.0B AUM | 0 clients · $600.0B AUM |
| Latest Audit Statistics | — | — |
| Services | Recordkeeping, Compliance Services | — |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP | 401(k), 403(b), 457 |
| Published Pricing | — | — |
| Locations | New York City, NY | Charlotte, NC, Charlotte, NC, New York, NY, Kansas City, MO |
Comparison Details
Voya vs TIAA: Comparing Two Major Retirement Plan Administrators Choosing between Voya Financial and TIAA often comes down to your organization type, the plan(s) you sponsor, and whether you value broad workplace-plan capabilities or a mission-driven provider with deep roots in higher education and nonprofits. Both are well-known retirement providers headquartered in New York, but they differ in legacy focus, plan breadth, and the way they typically serve employers and participants. At-a-Glance: Core Differences Provider scale: Voya lists ~ 9,000 employees , signaling a large national platform for employer retirement services. Legacy & market focus: TIAA was founded in 1918 and is closely associated with academic, medical, research, cultural, and public-service institutions. Plan support: Voya supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, and ESOP (plus broad “all” support). TIAA supports 401(k), 403(b), and 457 . Plan Types Supported: Breadth vs Specialization If your organization needs multiple retirement plan types under one umbrella, Voya’s broader plan coverage can be a deciding factor—especially for employers with a mix of qualified and non-qualified/governmental needs, or those maintaining legacy plan designs. Voya: 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit , ESOP TIAA: 401(k), 403(b), 457 For many higher-ed and nonprofit employers, a strong 403(b) platform and participant guidance may matter more than DB/ESOP support—an area where TIAA is often considered a natural fit given its long-standing institutional footprint. Services & Administration Capabilities Both providers operate in the retirement plan ecosystem, but the available service detail differs in the data provided. Voya explicitly lists compliance and recordkeeping , which are core administrator functions for employer-sponsored retirement plans. Voya services listed: compliance, recordkeeping TIAA services listed: not specified in the provided data (commonly associated with retirement, investment, and wealth management solutions) When comparing administrators, confirm who is doing what: recordkeeping, compliance testing, Form 5500 support (if applicable), vendor coordination for 403(b) environments, and how participant support is delivered (digital tools vs. dedicated counselors). Participant Experience & Investment Approach Voya emphasizes financial wellness, behavioral finance principles, and retirement readiness tools—useful for employers prioritizing engagement, education, and measurable participant outcomes. TIAA is well known for retirement income positioning and its TIAA Traditional annuity , which is often highlighted for guaranteed income features and long-term retirement security—particularly relevant for institutions with a culture of lifetime income planning. Pricing Transparency: What to Ask Neither provider includes public pricing in the information provided, which is common in the retirement plan industry because fees depend on plan size, complexity, share class selection, and service model. When evaluating Voya vs TIAA, request a proposal that itemizes: Recordkeeping/base administration fees (asset-based vs per-participant) Investment expense ratios and any revenue sharing Managed account/advice fees (if used) Plan document, compliance testing, and special project fees Which Administrator Is a Better Fit? Choose Voya if you want broad plan-type support (including defined benefit and ESOP ), explicit compliance/recordkeeping capabilities, and a large workplace-solutions platform serving diverse employer segments. Choose TIAA if you’re an academic, medical, research, cultural, nonprofit, or public-service institution that values a provider with a long legacy in these sectors and a strong emphasis on retirement income solutions like TIAA Traditional . For the best comparison, align each proposal to your plan’s goals—cost control, fiduciary process, participant outcomes, and retirement income readiness—then validate service responsibilities and reporting before making a change.