Vestwell vs Fidelity: Comparing Workplace Plans

Compare Vestwell and Fidelity Investments side by side.

CategoryVestwellFidelity Investments
Year Founded2,0161,949
Employees35050,000
HeadquartersNew York City, NYBoston, MA
Websitevestwell.com/fidelityworkplace.com/
ServicesCompliance Services, 3(16) Plan Administrator, 3(38) Investment Manager, Recordkeeping, 3(21) Investment AdvisorRecordkeeping
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Solo 401(k)401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit

Comparison Details

Vestwell and Fidelity both serve workplace retirement plans, but each describes distinct products and operating models. Vestwell spans retirement and other workplace savings; Fidelity publishes institutional defined-contribution services and a separate pooled plan for eligible first-time small-business sponsors. Specific duties and costs depend on the proposal and plan documents. Vestwell: retirement alongside workplace savings Vestwell describes 401(k), 403(b), and IRA plans, plan setup, recordkeeping, filings, compliance support, and onboarding. It lists payroll connections with more than 190 providers, plus 3(16) services. Vestwell says it can monitor investments and select funds when appointed as the plan’s 3(38) fiduciary; verify any such role in the agreement. Its wider workplace-savings menu includes state-facilitated, education, emergency, and ABLE savings, whose availability and administration should be confirmed for the employer. Fidelity: institutional services and a small-business PEP Fidelity’s institutional defined-contribution materials describe investment strategies across categories such as stable value, equity, fixed income, and multi-asset. Fidelity says plan administration and investment management may operate separately or together as a broader solution. That model gives sponsors a reason to examine how investment decisions, recordkeeping, participant support, and any outside advisor fit together. Fidelity Advantage 401(k) is a distinct pooled employer plan offered to eligible employers starting a first 401(k). Fidelity’s small-business information describes a streamlined plan with a simplified investment lineup. Treat Advantage as one product within Fidelity’s wider workplace business, not as a description of every Fidelity plan. Compare the service design Request a written map of who handles enrollment, payroll, eligibility, notices, filings, participant calls, loans, and distributions. Compare the actual investment menu and participant tools. For a PEP, identify its provider, delegated duties, employer touchpoints, and tasks retained by the adopting employer. Confirm the exact product, eligible employer profile, and supported plan types. Match payroll integration to your payroll vendor and confirm how exceptions are corrected. Identify each fiduciary role and the specific services covered by the contract. Compare implementation steps, conversion support, sponsor reporting, and service escalation. Review plan-specific disclosures and investment expenses using identical assumptions. Frequently asked questions Is Fidelity Advantage the same as Fidelity’s other workplace plans? No. Advantage is Fidelity’s named PEP for eligible employers establishing a first plan. Ask Fidelity which product and contract apply to your organization before comparing its duties or features with another provider’s arrangement. Which provider has better payroll integration? That depends on the employer’s payroll system and the plan configuration. Vestwell lists connections with more than 190 payroll providers; Fidelity’s institutional services should be evaluated against your specific payroll and data-feed requirements. Request a live workflow demonstration and a written exception process. Make the choice plan-specific Ask both teams to demonstrate the tasks your HR staff and employees will perform. Use the resulting workflow, written commitments, and complete fee disclosures to compare the proposals. Review the Vestwell profile , Fidelity profile , and provider comparison directory . Primary sources: Vestwell retirement plans , Fidelity institutional defined-contribution services , and Fidelity small-business 401(k) .