Vanguard vs Voya Financial

Compare The Vanguard Group, Inc. and Voya Financial side by side.

CategoryThe Vanguard Group, Inc.Voya Financial
Year Founded1,975—
Employees20,0009,000
HeadquartersMalvern, PANew York City, NY
Websiteworkplace.vanguard.com/homevoya.com/
Latest Client Statistics1,400 clients · $523.0B AUM65,135 clients · $729.0B AUM
ServicesPlan Design Consulting, Compliance Services, RecordkeepingRecordkeeping, Compliance Services
Plans SupportedSEP IRA, 401(k)401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP
Accreditations——
Published Pricing——
LocationsMalvern, PANew York City, NY

Comparison Details

Vanguard vs. Voya Financial: which retirement plan administrator fits your plan? Both The Vanguard Group, Inc. and Voya Financial offer retirement plan administration and recordkeeping, but they tend to win in different scenarios. Vanguard is widely associated with a low-cost, client-owned investment philosophy and strong institutional retirement capabilities. Voya is a broad workplace and retirement solutions provider with notable reach across corporate, tax-exempt, and government segments, supporting a wider range of plan types. At-a-glance comparison Provider type: Retirement plan administrators / recordkeepers Founded: Vanguard (1975) | Voya (not listed) Employees: Vanguard (~20,000) | Voya (~9,000) Primary services: Vanguard (recordkeeping, compliance, plan design) | Voya (recordkeeping, compliance) Plans supported: Vanguard (401(k), SEP IRA) | Voya (401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP, and more) Scale and market footprint Vanguard’s institutional scale and participant reach Vanguard’s retirement business is built for large-scale outcomes and operational consistency. In available 2024 stats for its 401(k) business, Vanguard supports approximately 1,400 plans and 4.8 million participants , with reported assets under administration around $2.55T . For plan sponsors, that scale can translate into mature processes, extensive operational experience, and institutional-grade technology and reporting. Voya’s breadth across employer segments Voya positions itself as a comprehensive workplace solutions provider, supporting a diverse mix of employer types (including tax-exempt and government). It lists support for 403(b) and 457 plans in addition to 401(k), and also references defined benefit and ESOP capabilities. If your organization needs an administrator that can cover multiple plan types under one umbrella (or you serve multiple sectors), Voya’s breadth may be a deciding factor. Plan types and “best fit” scenarios When Vanguard tends to be a strong fit 401(k)-focused sponsors who want a provider closely aligned with a low-cost investment lineup and a transparent, outcomes-oriented approach. Organizations prioritizing plan design support alongside core compliance and recordkeeping. Sponsors who value Vanguard’s client-owned structure and its emphasis on evidence-based plan design and participant outcomes. When Voya tends to be a strong fit Tax-exempt, education, healthcare, and government employers looking for deep support for 403(b) and 457 plans. Sponsors seeking a provider that integrates financial wellness messaging and behavioral finance concepts into participant engagement. Organizations that may need support across multiple plan types (e.g., 401(k) plus DB or other workplace programs). Services, support model, and participant experience Both providers offer the essentials— recordkeeping and compliance . Vanguard also highlights plan design as a core service, which can matter if you want help with features like auto-enrollment/auto-escalation strategy, eligibility, match design, and participant outcome improvements. Voya’s positioning emphasizes retirement readiness , financial literacy , and tools for employers and financial professionals—often appealing to sponsors who want a more holistic “workplace financial wellbeing” narrative. Pricing and transparency considerations Neither provider includes specific pricing in the data provided, so the decision typically comes down to how each proposal structures recordkeeping fees , asset-based charges , and any revenue sharing or fee offsets. When comparing quotes, ask both administrators for a line-item breakdown (base fee, per-participant fee, fund/managed account expenses, and any advisor or third-party costs) and request a clear illustration of total plan cost at your participant count and asset level. Bottom line Choose Vanguard if your priority is a 401(k)-centric administrator with large-scale institutional experience, a low-cost investment ethos, and strong plan design support. Choose Voya Financial if you need broader plan-type coverage (especially 403(b)/457), sector-specific workplace experience, and a wellness-forward participant engagement approach. The best next step is to compare proposals side-by-side using the same assumptions (participants, assets, payroll frequency, and desired plan features) to see which administrator delivers the best total value.