| Category | The Vanguard Group, Inc. | Principal Financial Group, Inc. |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,975 | 1,879 |
| Employees | 20,000 | 20,000 |
| Headquarters | Malvern, PA | Des Moines, IA |
| Website | workplace.vanguard.com/home | principal.com/individuals/invest-retire/retirement-plans/401k-403b-retirement-plans |
| Latest Client Statistics | 1,400 clients · $523.0B AUM | 11,086 clients · $540.4B AUM |
| Services | Plan Design Consulting, Compliance Services, Recordkeeping | Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, Recordkeeping, Participant Investment Advice |
| Plans Supported | SEP IRA, 401(k) | 401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP |
| Accreditations | — | — |
| Published Pricing | — | — |
| Locations | Malvern, PA | Des Moines, IA |
Comparison Details
Vanguard vs Principal: which retirement plan administrator is the better fit? Both The Vanguard Group and Principal Financial Group offer retirement plan administration and recordkeeping for employers, but they tend to win business for different reasons. Vanguard is best known for its low-cost investment philosophy and client-owned structure, while Principal pairs retirement plan services with a broader menu of financial and insurance solutions . Below is a practical comparison for plan sponsors evaluating Vanguard vs Principal . At-a-glance comparison Provider type: Both are retirement plan administrators/recordkeepers (not CPA firms). Founded: Vanguard (1975) vs Principal (1879). Employees: Both report ~20,000 employees. Core services: Both offer recordkeeping, compliance support, and plan design; Principal also highlights participant advice. Plan types supported: breadth vs focus Vanguard Vanguard supports 401(k) plans and SEP IRA arrangements. This narrower lineup can be an advantage if your organization wants a streamlined provider relationship centered on common defined contribution needs. Principal Principal supports a broader range of plan types, including 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit , and ESOP . That breadth can matter for organizations with multiple plan types (for example, public sector or nonprofit employers needing 403(b)/457 support, or sponsors maintaining a legacy pension plan). Services and participant experience Vanguard’s approach Vanguard positions its workplace offering around evidence-based plan design , dedicated sponsor support, and technology aimed at improving participant outcomes. A key differentiator is access to a wide range of low-cost Vanguard funds and ETFs , which can help sponsors align the investment menu with a cost-conscious philosophy. Principal’s approach Principal offers the expected administrative foundation— recordkeeping, compliance, and plan design —and additionally emphasizes participant advice . Principal also stands out as a diversified financial company with significant capabilities in employee benefits and insurance , which may appeal to employers looking to consolidate vendors across retirement and benefits. Scale and market footprint Provider scale can influence resources, service models, and long-term platform investment. Vanguard 401(k) scale (2024): ~ 1,400 clients, ~ 4.8 million participants, and approximately $2.55T in AUM (as reported in the provided data). Principal footprint (2025, selected plan types): ~ 2,286 403(b) clients (~ 642,825 participants), ~ 1,416 457 clients (~ 38,483 participants), and ~ 7,350 defined benefit clients (~ 1,265,335 participants) in the provided data. In practice, Vanguard’s numbers here highlight a very large defined contribution participant base, while Principal shows notable breadth across institutional segments like 403(b) and defined benefit. Pricing and transparency considerations Neither provider includes explicit pricing in the data provided, so sponsors should request a proposal that breaks out: Recordkeeping and administration fees (asset-based vs per-participant) Investment expense ratios and revenue-sharing assumptions Compliance/testing, distributions/loans, and plan document fees Any advice or managed account program costs Vanguard is often associated with transparent, low-cost investing , while Principal proposals may be especially relevant when bundling retirement + benefits/insurance services. Which administrator should you choose? Choose Vanguard if your priority is a DC-focused provider with a strong low-cost investment lineup and an outcomes-driven plan design philosophy—especially for core 401(k) needs. Choose Principal if you need 403(b), 457, defined benefit, or ESOP support, value participant advice offerings, or want a provider that can integrate retirement planning with broader financial/benefits solutions. For the most accurate Vanguard vs Principal decision, compare proposals side-by-side using the same census, match formula, eligibility rules, and investment menu assumptions—then evaluate total plan cost, service model, and participant outcomes.