UHY vs Bonadio

Compare UHY LLP and Bonadio & Co LLP side by side.

CategoryUHY LLPBonadio & Co LLP
Year Founded1,9571,978
Employees——
HeadquartersSt Louis, MOPittsford, NY
Websiteuhy-us.com/bonadio.com/
Latest Audit Statistics459 plans audited · $27.6B AUM430 plans audited · $46.7B AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare
AccreditationsAICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQCAICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC
Published Pricing——
LocationsSt Louis, MOPittsford, NY

Comparison Details

UHY LLP vs Bonadio & Co LLP: Which retirement plan auditor fits your plan? Choosing an employee benefit plan auditor is about more than a signature on a Form 5500 audit report. Plan sponsors often weigh firm depth, geographic coverage, experience across plan types, and demonstrated volume in benefit plan audits. Below is a practical comparison of UHY LLP and Bonadio & Co LLP (The Bonadio Group) for organizations evaluating a new auditor for a 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit , ESOP , or health & welfare plan. Firm profile and scale UHY LLP (founded 1957 ) is described as a top 30 U.S. accounting firm and an independent member of UHY International , a top global accounting network. UHY operates across 40+ offices and has 2,000+ professionals nationally, with a noted presence in St. Louis, MO . Bonadio & Co LLP (founded 1978 ) is positioned as a leading CPA firm and has been recognized as a Top 100 Accounting Firm . The Bonadio Group has offices across New York State and additional locations in Vermont, Texas, Delaware, Florida, and Virginia , including a referenced office in Pittsford, NY . How this impacts plan sponsors: UHY may appeal to organizations seeking a larger national footprint and access to a global network, while Bonadio can be a strong fit for sponsors wanting a firm with a concentrated presence in the Northeast plus select multi-state coverage. Plan types supported Both firms support a broad set of employee benefit plan audits, including: 401(k) plans 403(b) plans Defined benefit (pension) plans ESOPs Health & welfare plans Because both cover the major plan categories, the decision often comes down to audit team specialization, responsiveness, and experience with your plan’s specific features (e.g., multiple payroll feeds, acquisitions, complex eligibility, ESOP valuation coordination, or H&W claims administration controls). 401(k) audit volume and asset context (2024) One useful indicator of retirement plan audit familiarity is recent audit volume. Based on available 2024 401(k) audit stats: UHY LLP: 459 401(k) plans audited in 2024, representing approximately $27.6B in audited 401(k) plan assets. Bonadio & Co LLP: 430 401(k) plans audited in 2024, representing approximately $46.7B in audited 401(k) plan assets. What to take from this: UHY shows slightly higher 401(k) audit count, while Bonadio’s audited 401(k) asset total is higher—potentially signaling a greater share of larger plans in its 401(k) audit mix. If your plan is large or has complex investments, asking about the team’s experience with similar-sized plans and custody/recordkeeper environments can be especially relevant. Geography and service model considerations UHY may be a strong match for sponsors that want a broad U.S. office network and the option to align benefit plan audits with other national tax/audit/advisory needs. Bonadio may be attractive to organizations that prefer a firm with deep regional roots (particularly in New York) but still want multi-state support. Pricing and scoping: what to ask (since public pricing varies) Neither firm publishes standard audit pricing here, so the best comparison comes from a like-for-like proposal. When requesting quotes, ask both auditors to confirm: Whether the audit will be ERISA full-scope or limited-scope (when eligible) and how that affects fees Expected PBC (prepared-by-client) list and timelines Experience with your recordkeeper/custodian and typical turnaround time for confirmations and schedules How they handle plan document failures , operational issues, and management letter recommendations Who performs the work (partner/manager continuity) and the communication cadence Bottom line: UHY vs Bonadio If you prioritize a larger national platform and global network affiliation, UHY LLP is compelling. If you want a Top 100 firm with strong Northeast presence and evidence of auditing higher aggregate 401(k) assets in 2024, Bonadio & Co LLP is a strong contender. The best next step is to request proposals scoped to your plan’s participant count, payroll complexity, and recordkeeper environment, then compare timelines, staffing, and deliverables—not just price.