Transamerica vs. Fidelity: Employer Retirement Plan Comparison

Compare Transamerica and Fidelity Investments side by side.

CategoryTransamericaFidelity Investments
Year Founded1,9461,949
Employees—50,000
HeadquartersCedar Rapids, IABoston, MA
Websitetransamerica.com/employer/retirement/employer-sponsored-retirement-plansfidelityworkplace.com/
ServicesParticipant Investment Advice, Plan Design Consulting, RecordkeepingRecordkeeping
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), 457, Solo 401(k), SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA, Defined Benefit, ESOP401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit

Comparison Details

Choosing between Transamerica and Fidelity starts with the plan you need, the work you want handled, and the services your employees will use. Both providers offer workplace retirement solutions, but their public materials describe different programs for different employer situations. The details of any proposal depend on plan design, workforce, selected services, investments, and contract terms. Transamerica’s employer plan approach Transamerica describes flexible retirement recordkeeping, qualified and nonqualified plan options, and pooled plans. Its employer materials highlight healthcare, higher education, and nonprofit experience. Confirm the services included in your proposal. Fidelity’s employer plan approach Fidelity provides workplace retirement services across employer segments. One distinct small-business option is Fidelity Advantage 401(k), a pooled employer plan intended for eligible for-profit employers establishing a plan for the first time. Fidelity says it serves as the pooled plan sponsor and fiduciary and handles many day-to-day responsibilities for that arrangement. That product is only one part of Fidelity’s workplace business; it should not be treated as a description of every Fidelity 401(k) plan. For an existing plan or a larger workforce, ask Fidelity to identify the exact recordkeeping, investment, advice, and administration services proposed. What to compare for your organization Start with fit rather than a provider-wide ranking. A first-time small employer considering a pooled plan should compare the plan sponsor’s duties, required employer contributions, payroll process, eligibility rules, and the tasks that remain with the adopting employer. An established plan should compare the proposed recordkeeping model, plan design support, investment menu, participant education, service contacts, and transition process. Employers with healthcare, education, nonprofit, or multi-plan needs can ask each provider to show relevant experience and explain how their services fit together. Ask for the full service agreement and a written responsibility chart. Compare investment choices and related expenses using the actual plan lineup. Review participant access, enrollment support, loans and distributions, and service hours. Request a plan-specific fee disclosure and distinguish employer-paid from participant-paid costs. Confirm data feeds, payroll integration, implementation timing, and conversion support. Frequently asked questions Is Fidelity Advantage the same as Fidelity’s other workplace plans? No. Fidelity describes Advantage as a pooled employer plan for eligible employers starting a first-time plan. Ask which Fidelity product and contract apply to your organization before comparing responsibilities or features. Which provider costs less? There is no universal published price that determines the cost for every employer. Request current, plan-specific disclosures that show recordkeeping, investment, transaction, and optional service costs on the same basis. Make the comparison plan-specific Transamerica and Fidelity can each be evaluated across plan design, administration, participant experience, and workplace benefits. Compare the exact proposals and identify who performs each task before choosing. Read the Transamerica profile , Fidelity profile , and provider comparison directory for more context. Primary sources: Transamerica employer retirement plans , Fidelity Advantage 401(k) , and Fidelity workplace services .