The Hartford vs Travelers

Compare The Hartford and Travelers Casualty and Surety ERISA Bonds side by side.

CategoryThe HartfordTravelers Casualty and Surety ERISA Bonds
Year Founded1,8101,864
Employees——
HeadquartersHartford, CTHartford, CT
Websitethehartford.com/travelers.com/
Accreditations——
LocationsHartford, CTHartford, CT

Comparison Details

The Hartford vs Travelers: ERISA Fidelity Bonds for 401(k) and 403(b) Plans Choosing between The Hartford and Travelers Casualty and Surety often comes down to how your plan wants to approach ERISA Fidelity Bond compliance and broader risk management. Both insurers are established U.S. carriers headquartered in Hartford, Connecticut , and both support bonding needs for common retirement plan types like 401(k) and 403(b) plans. Below is a practical comparison to help plan sponsors and administrators select the right ERISA bonding partner. What ERISA Fidelity Bonds Cover (and Why They’re Required) Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) , every person who “handles” plan funds typically must be bonded. An ERISA Fidelity Bond is first-party protection for the plan—designed to help reimburse losses from fraud or dishonesty (for example, theft or embezzlement) involving plan assets. Minimum coverage often starts at $1,000. Coverage amount is generally at least 10% of plan assets handled. Maximum limits commonly reach $500,000, or up to $1,000,000 for plans holding employer/company stock (as described in typical ERISA bonding guidance). Key Differences Between The Hartford and Travelers Company history and stability The Hartford (founded 1810 ) is one of the oldest U.S. insurers, often appealing to plan fiduciaries who value long operating history and institutional familiarity. Travelers (founded 1864 ) is also a legacy carrier with a deep footprint in business insurance and surety—an advantage for employers who prefer a provider known for commercial risk programs. ERISA bond positioning and specialization Both offer ERISA Fidelity Bonds designed to satisfy federal requirements, but their positioning differs slightly: The Hartford emphasizes ERISA bonding as part of a broader retirement plan protection approach and highlights coverage guidance, including common limit ranges and plan stock considerations. Travelers Casualty and Surety highlights a specialized ERISA Fidelity policy tailored for ERISA-covered plans , which may resonate if you want a product framed specifically around ERISA-only exposures and compliance needs. Beyond the bond: additional fiduciary risk protection A major differentiator is how each insurer is presented in relation to adjacent coverages: The Hartford explicitly notes availability of Fiduciary Liability Insurance alongside the ERISA bond. This can be helpful if you’re looking to pair the required bond with coverage that addresses mismanagement allegations (a separate risk from theft/dishonesty). Travelers messaging in this comparison is more focused on the ERISA Fidelity bond itself and ensuring the plan meets legal obligations with the proper limit and structure. How to Choose: The Hartford or Travelers? Choose The Hartford if: You want ERISA bonding plus a clear path to bundling with fiduciary liability insurance . You value a very long-standing insurance brand (founded 1810) and want a provider positioned around retirement plan protections. Choose Travelers if: You prefer an insurer emphasizing a specialized ERISA-focused fidelity policy and straightforward compliance alignment. Your organization already uses Travelers for other commercial coverages and wants consistency in carrier relationships. Bottom Line Both The Hartford and Travelers are credible choices for ERISA Fidelity Bonds for 401(k) and 403(b) plans. If you’re deciding between them, focus on (1) whether you want a broader fiduciary protection package beyond the bond, (2) how you prefer the bond program to be positioned (general retirement plan protection vs ERISA-specialized framing), and (3) how the carrier fits into your existing insurance ecosystem. Next step: confirm your plan’s required bond amount (typically 10% of assets handled, subject to ERISA limits) and request quotes that match your plan’s asset size, handling practices, and any employer stock features.