| Category | The Hartford | Nationwide |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,810 | 1,926 |
| Employees | — | — |
| Headquarters | Hartford, CT | Columbus, OH |
| Website | thehartford.com/ | nationwide.com/ |
| Accreditations | — | — |
| Locations | Hartford, CT | Columbus, OH |
Comparison Details
The Hartford vs Nationwide: ERISA Fidelity Bond Insurance for 401(k) & 403(b) Plans If you sponsor a 401(k) or 403(b) plan, an ERISA fidelity bond is typically required to protect participants from losses caused by fraud or dishonesty by people who handle plan funds. Both The Hartford and Nationwide offer ERISA bond coverage aimed at meeting federal requirements, but they differ in positioning, breadth of related protections, and how plan sponsors may evaluate fit. At-a-glance comparison Provider type: Insurers offering ERISA fidelity bonds Plans supported: The Hartford: 401(k), 403(b) | Nationwide: 401(k), 403(b) Headquarters: The Hartford (Hartford, CT) | Nationwide (Columbus, OH) Founded: The Hartford (1810) | Nationwide (1926) Coverage requirements: where both insurers align ERISA generally requires bonding for every person who “handles” plan funds. Many plans target coverage of at least 10% of plan assets handled , subject to minimums and maximums. When comparing insurers, confirm the bond is written specifically as an ERISA fidelity bond (not a generic commercial crime policy) and that it names the plan appropriately to satisfy compliance expectations. Key differences between The Hartford and Nationwide 1) Depth of ERISA-focused guidance and compliance framing The Hartford is positioned as a long-established provider (founded in 1810 ) with messaging that directly references ERISA compliance details and typical bond sizing. In particular, The Hartford commonly highlights practical parameters plan sponsors look for, including typical minimums and maximums and the special higher cap for plans holding employer securities. Nationwide also markets ERISA bond coverage as part of broader business insurance solutions, emphasizing the role of bonding in protecting participants and meeting legal requirements. Plan sponsors who prefer a straightforward bond purchase within a broader insurer relationship may find this approach appealing. 2) Coverage limits and plan scenarios Based on publicly described parameters, The Hartford references common ERISA bond ranges such as $1,000 minimum up to $500,000 , and up to $1 million for plans holding company stock . If your plan includes employer securities, that explicit alignment can be a useful comparison point when you’re validating the bond limit you may need. Nationwide promotes comprehensive ERISA bond coverage but does not emphasize specific limit ranges in the provided overview. If you’re comparing the two, ask Nationwide for limit options tailored to your plan assets, plus how quickly limits can be adjusted as assets grow. 3) Bundling with fiduciary risk protection A frequent point of confusion: an ERISA bond protects the plan from dishonest acts, while fiduciary liability insurance helps protect the sponsor/committee from claims alleging mismanagement. The Hartford explicitly highlights offering Fiduciary Liability Insurance alongside ERISA bonds, which may be valuable if you want a more complete risk-management package under one carrier. Nationwide is widely known for broad commercial insurance offerings; if you already use Nationwide for business coverage, you may prefer consolidating policies. Confirm whether fiduciary liability coverage is available and how it integrates with your ERISA bond and other management liability policies. How to choose between The Hartford and Nationwide If you want ERISA-specific clarity: The Hartford’s ERISA bond framing (including typical limit guidance and company-stock scenarios) can make compliance planning simpler. If you prefer consolidating business insurance: Nationwide may fit well when you want ERISA bonding through an insurer you already work with for other lines. If you need broader fiduciary protection: Compare quotes that include both an ERISA bond and fiduciary liability insurance, and review exclusions, limits, and claim support. Next step: request quotes and confirm plan details Before purchasing, verify your plan’s current asset value, whether it holds employer securities, who handles plan funds, and the exact bond limit required. Then request quotes from The Hartford and Nationwide and compare total cost, limit flexibility, and whether you can bundle fiduciary liability coverage for a more complete ERISA risk solution.