RSM vs Grant Thornton

Compare RSM LLP and Grant Thornton LLP side by side.

CategoryRSM LLPGrant Thornton LLP
Year Founded1,9261,924
Employees——
HeadquartersChicago, ILOakbrook Terrace, IL
Websitersmus.com/grantthornton.com/
Latest Audit Statistics989 plans audited · $111.6B AUM798 plans audited · $403.0B AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare
Accreditations—AICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member
Published Pricing——
LocationsChicago, IL, Phoenix, AZOakbrook Terrace, IL

Comparison Details

RSM LLP vs Grant Thornton LLP: Which retirement plan auditor is the better fit? Choosing an ERISA retirement plan auditor is about more than brand recognition. Plan sponsors typically weigh relevant plan-audit experience, the auditor’s ability to handle complex plan features, responsiveness during fieldwork, and how well the firm supports your internal team and third-party providers. Below is a practical comparison of RSM US LLP and Grant Thornton LLP for retirement plan audits, based on the information provided and reported 2024 401(k) audit activity. At-a-glance comparison Firm type: National CPA firms offering Audit & Assurance, Tax, and Advisory/Consulting services Founded: RSM (1926) vs Grant Thornton (1924) Headquarters: RSM (Chicago, IL) vs Grant Thornton (Oakbrook Terrace, IL) Plans supported: Both list support for 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, and health & welfare plans Retirement plan audit volume and scale (2024 401(k)) One way to gauge specialization and bench strength is to look at annual plan-audit volume. In 2024, both firms show substantial 401(k) audit activity, with RSM reporting higher plan count and significantly higher audited assets under management (AUM) in the provided data. RSM 401(k) audits (2024): 989 plans audited; $111.63B AUM Grant Thornton 401(k) audits (2024): 798 plans audited; $402.99B AUM How to interpret this: Higher plan count can indicate repeatable processes, deeper retirement-plan audit teams, and familiarity with common recordkeepers and custodians. Higher AUM can signal exposure to larger, more complex plans (though AUM can be influenced by a small number of very large plans). Sponsors should ask which office/team will actually perform the work and what their direct experience is with your plan’s design and providers. Plan types and complexity coverage Both RSM and Grant Thornton indicate support across major ERISA plan categories: Defined contribution: 401(k) and 403(b) Defined benefit: pension plans with actuarial and benefit payment considerations ESOPs: employer stock valuation and unique compliance requirements Health & welfare: eligibility, claims, and premium/benefit administration testing If your plan includes more advanced features—like multiple payroll feeds, frequent acquisitions, complex eligibility classes, after-tax or Roth sources, or participant loan volume—request examples of how each firm tests these areas and coordinates with your recordkeeper and TPA. Service model and what sponsors should ask Both firms are large professional services organizations, but sponsor experience can vary by office and engagement team. RSM highlights a middle-market focus, which may appeal to sponsors wanting a national firm with a strong process orientation for growing organizations. Grant Thornton positions itself as a large CPA firm with broad industry coverage and data-driven insights, which may be attractive for sponsors seeking robust advisory depth alongside audit execution. Engagement staffing: Who is the day-to-day manager? How many plan audits do they run each season? Timeline discipline: What is the typical PBC (prepared-by-client) list, and how do they manage late items? Coordination: How do they work with your recordkeeper, custodian, and TPA to reduce rework? Issue prevention: Do they provide pre-audit readiness guidance (e.g., SOC report review, eligibility sampling approach)? Pricing and value considerations Neither provider includes public pricing in the supplied data, which is common for ERISA audits. In practice, audit fees are driven by participant count, number of payrolls and locations, plan features (loans, employer securities, forfeitures), quality of plan administration, and the condition of your prior-year workpapers. Tip: When comparing proposals, ask each firm to break down assumptions (participant count, sample sizes, use of SOC reports, and expected PBC quality) so you can compare scope consistently—not just the bottom-line fee. Bottom line: RSM vs Grant Thornton Choose RSM if you value a national auditor with strong middle-market positioning and high 401(k) audit volume in the provided dataset. Choose Grant Thornton if you want a large firm with broad advisory capabilities and experience that may skew toward larger-plan complexity (as suggested by the higher reported AUM). In either case, the best decision typically comes down to the specific engagement team, their retirement plan audit specialization, and how well their process fits your plan’s operational reality.