| Category | Principal Financial Group, Inc. | Nationwide |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,879 | 1,926 |
| Employees | 20,000 | — |
| Headquarters | Des Moines, IA | Columbus, OH |
| Website | principal.com/individuals/invest-retire/retirement-plans/401k-403b-retirement-plans | nationwide.com/ |
| Latest Client Statistics | 11,086 clients · $540.4B AUM | — |
| Services | Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, Recordkeeping, Participant Investment Advice | — |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP | 401(k), 403(b) |
| Accreditations | — | — |
| Published Pricing | — | — |
| Locations | Des Moines, IA | Columbus, OH |
Comparison Details
Principal vs Nationwide: Which retirement plan administrator fits your organization? Choosing between Principal Financial Group and Nationwide depends on what you need from an “administrator.” Principal is positioned as a full-service retirement plan provider (recordkeeping, compliance support, plan design, and participant guidance). Nationwide, based on the information available, is best known here for business insurance —specifically 401(k) ERISA bond coverage —which is a related but distinct need from day-to-day retirement plan administration. At-a-glance comparison Headquarters: Principal (Des Moines, IA) vs Nationwide (Columbus, OH) Founded: 1879 (Principal) vs 1926 (Nationwide) Scale: Principal ~20,000 employees; Nationwide employee count not provided Plan types supported (per provided data): Principal supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, and ESOP; Nationwide supports 401(k) and 403(b) Core offering differences Principal: full retirement plan administration + participant support Principal’s retirement plan offering is built around ongoing plan operations. Based on the provided services, Principal can act as a comprehensive partner across: Recordkeeping: maintaining participant accounts, contributions, distributions, and reporting Compliance support: helping employers stay aligned with ERISA and IRS requirements Plan design: guidance on eligibility, match/profit sharing structures, and plan features Participant advice: education and guidance intended to improve retirement readiness Principal also supports a broader set of plan types beyond 401(k)/403(b), including 457 , defined benefit , and ESOP , which can matter if you anticipate plan complexity or multiple benefit programs. Nationwide: insurance-led support (ERISA bond focus) Nationwide is presented primarily as an insurance provider with an emphasis on ERISA bonds for 401(k) plans. An ERISA bond is often required when plan fiduciaries handle plan assets, and it’s designed to protect the plan against losses from fraud or dishonesty. If your main gap is securing or updating ERISA bond coverage, Nationwide may be a practical fit. However, ERISA bond coverage is not the same as recordkeeping or plan administration. If you’re comparing these providers specifically as “administrators,” confirm what Nationwide provides beyond insurance (e.g., recordkeeping, compliance testing, participant servicing) before deciding. Plan type breadth and organizational fit When Principal may be the better fit You want a single provider for administration functions like recordkeeping, compliance support, and participant guidance. You sponsor (or may add) 457 , defined benefit , or ESOP plans in addition to a 401(k)/403(b). You value provider scale and longevity (founded 1879; ~20,000 employees). When Nationwide may be the better fit Your priority is ERISA bond coverage as part of risk management for your retirement plan. You prefer to keep administration with one firm and place bond/insurance with a specialized carrier. Scale and market presence (based on provided client stats) Principal shows measurable presence across multiple plan types in the provided 2025 client statistics, including 403(b) , 457 , and defined benefit plans. While AUM is not listed here, the participant counts indicate a large servicing footprint across these segments. Nationwide client statistics were not provided in the data set, so a direct side-by-side scale comparison for retirement administration isn’t available. Pricing and next steps No pricing details were provided for either provider. For an accurate comparison, request proposals that break out: Base recordkeeping/administration fees (fixed and/or asset-based) Compliance and testing support scope Participant services (education, advice availability, call center support) Any insurance requirements (including ERISA bond) and who provides them If you’re seeking a retirement plan administrator with broad plan support and bundled services, Principal is the clearer match based on the information provided. If you’re primarily solving for ERISA bond coverage , Nationwide is directly aligned with that need.