Plante Moran vs Eide Bailly

Compare PLANTE & MORAN, PLLC and Eide Bailly LLP side by side.

CategoryPLANTE & MORAN, PLLCEide Bailly LLP
Year Founded1,9241,998
Employees—3,300
Headquarters—Fargo, ND
Websiteplantemoran.com/www.eidebailly.com/
Latest Audit Statistics1,216 plans audited · $158.8B AUM1,147 plans audited · $97.2B AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare
AccreditationsAICPA EBPAQC, AICPA MemberAICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member
Published Pricing——
Locations—Fargo, ND

Comparison Details

Plante Moran vs. Eide Bailly: choosing an employee benefit plan auditor When you’re selecting an ERISA employee benefit plan auditor , the most practical differentiators are (1) demonstrated experience with your plan type, (2) the firm’s scale and bench strength, (3) geographic coverage, and (4) how their audit practice aligns with your plan’s complexity (multiple payrolls, acquisitions, ESOP activity, or defined benefit funding considerations). Below is a side-by-side comparison of PLANTE & MORAN, PLLC and Eide Bailly LLP for organizations evaluating an auditor for a 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit plan, or ESOP. At-a-glance comparison Founded: Plante Moran (1924) vs. Eide Bailly (1998) Headquarters: Eide Bailly (Fargo, ND); Plante Moran (not listed in provided data) Employees: Eide Bailly (3,300); Plante Moran (not listed in provided data) Plan types supported: Plante Moran: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP Eide Bailly: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, health & welfare Scale and recent 401(k) audit activity Both firms are positioned as large U.S. CPA and advisory firms, but their recent 401(k) audit volume and the assets under management (AUM) represented in the audit dataset can help indicate the size and complexity they routinely support. Plante Moran 401(k) audits 2025: 1,216 plans audited; ~ $158.8B AUM represented 2024: 3 plans audited; ~ $32.4M AUM represented Plante Moran is described as among the largest CPA and business advisory firms in the U.S., with broad capabilities spanning audit, tax, investment banking, wealth management, and international consulting. If your organization values a long operating history and the ability to pull in adjacent advisory resources (e.g., transactions, international operations, or complex accounting matters), Plante Moran’s platform may be a fit. Eide Bailly 401(k) audits 2024: 1,147 plans audited; ~ $97.2B AUM represented Eide Bailly is also recognized as one of the largest accounting firms in the U.S. and notes a footprint of 50+ offices across the U.S. and India with 3,300+ staff . For sponsors that prefer a clearly stated national footprint and staffing scale—especially those with multi-state operations—Eide Bailly’s reach can be a practical advantage. Plan coverage and specialization considerations Both providers support core retirement plan audits (401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, and ESOP). A meaningful difference is that Eide Bailly also lists health & welfare plan support , which may matter if you want to consolidate audits for multiple ERISA plan types under one firm. If you only need a retirement plan audit: either firm may be suitable based on fit, responsiveness, and industry experience. If you need both retirement and health & welfare audits: Eide Bailly may reduce vendor sprawl by covering both. How to decide between Plante Moran and Eide Bailly Choose Plante Moran if you prioritize a long-established firm (founded 1924) and value access to broad advisory lines that may support complex sponsor needs. Choose Eide Bailly if you want a clearly defined large workforce (3,300) and office footprint, and/or you want one firm that can also audit health & welfare plans. Questions to ask both auditors before you sign Who will be the engagement partner and day-to-day manager, and what is their benefit plan audit specialization? What is your timeline for PBC requests, fieldwork, and report issuance? How do you handle common 401(k) audit issues (late deferrals, eligibility errors, forfeitures, SOC reports, and payroll data reconciliation)? Do you have experience with our plan type nuances (403(b) universal availability, ESOP valuations, DB actuarial coordination)? How is pricing structured (fixed fee vs. hourly), and what triggers change orders? Ultimately, both Plante Moran and Eide Bailly show substantial 401(k) audit activity in the dataset and support key retirement plan types. Your best choice will come down to the engagement team’s benefit plan depth, your preferred footprint, and whether you want to bundle additional ERISA audits like health & welfare under the same provider.