Paychex vs Guideline

Compare Paychex and Guideline, Inc. side by side.

CategoryPaychexGuideline, Inc.
Year Founded1,9712,015
Employees15,000350
HeadquartersRochester, NYBurlingame, CA
Websitepaychex.com/guideline.com/
Latest Client Statistics124,000 clients · $55.7B AUM60,000 clients · $15.0B AUM
Services3(16) Plan Administrator, Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, 3(21) Investment Advisor, 3(38) Investment ManagerFiduciary Audit Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(16) Plan Administrator, Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, Participant Investment Advice, 3(38) Investment Manager
Plans Supported401(k)401(k), Solo 401(k), SEP IRA
Accreditations——
Published Pricing—Core: $89 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee
Enterprise: $149 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee
Starter: $39 base fee, $4/employee, $0 setup fee
LocationsRochester, NYBurlingame, CA

Comparison Details

Paychex vs Guideline: Which 401(k) Administrator Fits Your Business? Choosing between Paychex and Guideline often comes down to what you value most in a 401(k) administrator: a long-established payroll/HR provider with large-scale recordkeeping, or a modern, tech-forward platform with transparent pricing and built-in fiduciary services. Below is a practical comparison to help you decide. Company snapshot and scale Paychex (founded 1971, HQ Rochester, NY) is a major payroll and HR services company that also provides retirement services and recordkeeping . It reports substantial 401(k) scale with about 124,000 plans , roughly $55.7B in AUM , and about 1.61M participants (2025 data). Guideline (founded 2015, HQ Burlingame, CA) is a fintech retirement provider offering an integrated platform across administration, investments, and payroll sync. It reports about 60,000 401(k) clients , about $15B in AUM , and around 500,000 participants (2026 data). What this means: Paychex is the larger, more established player—often attractive for businesses wanting a single vendor for payroll/HR plus retirement recordkeeping at scale. Guideline is smaller but purpose-built for streamlined plan management with a software-first experience. Services and fiduciary support Both providers support 401(k) plans, but their service depth differs. Paychex services: Primarily positioned here as recordkeeping within a broader payroll/HR ecosystem. Guideline services: Recordkeeping plus 3(16) administrative fiduciary , 3(38) investment fiduciary , participant advice , compliance , and plan design . Guideline also highlights an integrated approach through its subsidiaries (including an SEC-registered investment adviser) and model portfolios built with low-cost funds. Decision tip: If you want a provider that can take on more fiduciary and compliance workload (e.g., 3(16)/3(38) options) within one platform, Guideline stands out in this comparison. Pricing transparency Pricing clarity can be a major differentiator when comparing retirement plan administrators. Guideline pricing (published tiers): Starter: $39/month base + $4/employee/month, $0 setup Core: $89/month base + $8/employee/month, $0 setup Enterprise: $149/month base + $8/employee/month, $0 setup Paychex pricing: Not provided in the data here, and often varies based on bundled payroll/HR services, company size, and plan needs. Decision tip: If you prefer predictable, easy-to-compare monthly pricing, Guideline’s tiered model is simpler to evaluate. If you want a bundled payroll + HR + retirement package, Paychex may be better suited—just expect a custom quote process. Plan types supported Paychex: 401(k) Guideline: 401(k), Solo 401(k) , and SEP IRA If you’re a self-employed owner evaluating a Solo 401(k) or considering a SEP IRA alternative, Guideline offers more plan-type flexibility based on the data provided. Integrations and user experience Paychex is widely known for payroll and HR administration, which can be appealing if you want retirement administration closely tied to an established payroll provider. Guideline emphasizes a technology-driven experience and payroll synchronization, including well-known integrations (such as with Gusto) to streamline contributions and reduce administrative friction. Bottom line: Paychex or Guideline? Choose Paychex if you want an established, large-scale provider and prefer consolidating payroll/HR and retirement recordkeeping under a single brand. Choose Guideline if you want transparent pricing, modern administration workflows, and expanded fiduciary/compliance service options (including 3(16) and 3(38)). Next step: list your must-haves (plan type, fiduciary support, payroll integration, pricing predictability), then request a proposal from each to compare total costs and service responsibilities side-by-side.