Lincoln Financial vs Nationwide

Compare Lincoln Financial Group and Nationwide side by side.

CategoryLincoln Financial GroupNationwide
Year Founded1,9051,926
Employees11,000—
HeadquartersRadnor, PAColumbus, OH
Websitelincolnfinancial.com/public/employers/products/employerretirementplansnationwide.com/
Latest Client Statistics21,200 clients · $116.4B AUM—
ServicesCompliance Services, Recordkeeping—
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP401(k), 403(b)
Accreditations——
Published Pricing——
LocationsHartford, CT, Fort Wayne, IN, Omaha, NE, Radnor, PAColumbus, OH

Comparison Details

Lincoln Financial vs Nationwide: which administrator is the better fit? Employers comparing Lincoln Financial Group and Nationwide are often trying to answer a simple question: “Who can reliably run our retirement plan?” The key difference is scope. Lincoln Financial is positioned as a full retirement plan services provider (administration and recordkeeping), while Nationwide is presented primarily as an insurance provider offering ERISA bond coverage—an important requirement for many plans, but not the same as day-to-day plan administration. At-a-glance comparison Founded: Lincoln Financial (1905) vs Nationwide (1926) Headquarters: Radnor, PA vs Columbus, OH Plan types supported: Lincoln Financial supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, and ESOP; Nationwide lists 401(k) and 403(b) Core offering shown: Lincoln Financial highlights employer retirement plan services; Nationwide highlights ERISA bond coverage for plan fiduciaries Services and capabilities Lincoln Financial Group: retirement plan services + recordkeeping Lincoln Financial Group is a large, established financial services company (about 11,000 employees ) with dedicated employer retirement plan offerings. For sponsors looking for an administrator/recordkeeper, Lincoln Financial’s stated services include recordkeeping and compliance , which typically map to core needs like plan operations, required notices, contribution processing workflows, and support for ongoing regulatory requirements. Lincoln Financial also supports a broader mix of plan designs—particularly relevant if you operate in sectors where 403(b) and 457 plans are common (nonprofits, education, and government), or if you need support beyond defined contribution (e.g., defined benefit or ESOP ). Nationwide: insurance-led offering (ERISA bond focus) Nationwide’s public positioning in the provided description centers on business insurance and 401(k) ERISA bonds . ERISA bonds are often required when plan fiduciaries handle plan funds, and they help protect the plan against losses due to dishonest acts. This is a valuable component of a retirement plan’s risk management and compliance posture, but it is not a substitute for a retirement plan administrator/recordkeeper. If your main need is fulfilling bonding requirements (or reviewing them), Nationwide may fit as a specialized insurance solution. If you’re looking for full retirement plan administration, you’ll want to confirm whether Nationwide is acting as the administrator/recordkeeper for your plan or primarily as an insurance provider. Scale and plan experience Lincoln Financial’s scale shows up in available client statistics for multiple plan types. For example, Lincoln Financial reports substantial presence in: 403(b): 10,568 clients and 760,206 participants (2025) 457: 1,902 clients and 107,320 participants (2025) Defined benefit: 1,108 clients and 133,962 participants (2025) Nationwide client statistics were not provided here, so the comparison on measurable plan scale is clearer for Lincoln Financial in this dataset. Pricing transparency Neither provider includes pricing details in the supplied data. In practice, retirement plan costs can include recordkeeping fees, asset-based fees, participant fees, and plan-level compliance/administration charges. When comparing, request a full fee breakdown and confirm what’s included (e.g., compliance testing support, distributions/loans processing, participant education tools, and employer support model). Which should you choose? Choose Lincoln Financial if you want a full-service retirement plan provider with explicit recordkeeping and compliance capabilities and support for a wide range of plan types (including 403(b), 457, defined benefit, and ESOP). Choose Nationwide if your immediate need is ERISA bond coverage or an insurance-focused solution tied to retirement plan fiduciary requirements—and verify whether separate administration/recordkeeping is needed. For most employers seeking an “administrator” comparison, the deciding factor is whether you need ongoing plan operations (where Lincoln Financial is clearly positioned) versus a specific compliance insurance product (where Nationwide is clearly positioned).