Ice Miller vs Faegre Drinker

Compare Ice Miller LLP and Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP side by side.

CategoryIce Miller LLPFaegre Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP
Year Founded1,9102,020
Employees2,675—
HeadquartersIndianapolis, INIndianapolis, IN
Websiteicemiller.com/faegredrinker.com/
Accreditations——
LocationsPhiladelphia, PA, Washington, DC, Miami, FL, Baltimore, MD, Naples, FL, New York, NY, Indianapolis, IN, Cleveland, OH, Chicago, IL, Milwaukee, WI, Columbus, OHIndianapolis, IN

Comparison Details

Ice Miller vs Faegre Drinker: ERISA & Retirement Plan Attorney Comparison Choosing between Ice Miller LLP and Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP often comes down to what kind of retirement plan legal support you need most: ongoing plan counseling and compliance, or a firm that heavily emphasizes ERISA litigation defense and high-stakes disputes. Both are national law firms that support common plan types— 401(k) , 403(b) , and defined benefit (pension) plans—and both list Indianapolis, IN as a headquarters location, making them relevant options for Midwest-based sponsors as well as organizations with multi-state operations. At-a-glance: what’s similar Provider type: ERISA/employee benefits attorneys (law firms) Plans supported: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit Typical matters: compliance, fiduciary duties, plan governance, and risk management Key differences 1) Firm history and scale Ice Miller was founded in 1910 and reports approximately 2,675 employees , positioning it as a long-established firm with a sizable operational footprint and deep institutional experience. Its website and firm overview emphasize broad, full-service capabilities across industries and practice areas, with employee benefits as one component of a wider platform. Faegre Drinker lists a founding year of 2020 (reflecting the modern combined firm identity) and is described as a leading firm for ERISA matters. While employee count is not provided here, its positioning in this comparison leans heavily into benefits and executive compensation, particularly where disputes and investigations are involved. 2) Geographic footprint and accessibility Ice Miller highlights a multi-office presence including Indianapolis, Chicago, Columbus, Cleveland, Milwaukee, Washington D.C., New York, Philadelphia, Miami and more. If your plan committee values frequent in-person access across multiple regions—or you operate in several of these markets—Ice Miller’s footprint may be a practical advantage. Faegre Drinker also serves clients nationally and is positioned as a go-to firm for complex ERISA issues across jurisdictions, particularly in federal litigation and regulatory matters. 3) Counseling vs. litigation emphasis Ice Miller’s description emphasizes strategic counsel on complex benefits matters—plan compliance, fiduciary responsibilities, and navigating business events (e.g., transactions, data/privacy concerns that may intersect with benefits administration). This can be a fit for sponsors looking for ongoing governance support, document work, and preventative risk reduction. Faegre Drinker is explicitly framed around ERISA litigation and counseling , including breach of fiduciary duty claims , class action defense , plan administration disputes, and government investigations . If your organization is facing (or wants to prepare for) heightened litigation exposure, this focus may matter. How to choose between Ice Miller and Faegre Drinker Choose Ice Miller if you want: A long-tenured firm ( founded 1910 ) with a large employee base and broad service platform Benefits counsel integrated with other business legal needs (transactions, privacy/data, litigation support) Access to a wide set of offices for multi-state operations Choose Faegre Drinker if you want: A firm strongly positioned for ERISA litigation and high-stakes fiduciary disputes Support for class action defense , investigations, and contested plan administration matters Benefits and executive compensation counsel designed to minimize risk in evolving ERISA enforcement Questions to ask both firms (pricing and scope) Neither provider lists public pricing here, so it’s smart to request a written scope and staffing plan. Ask both: Who will be day-to-day counsel (partner vs. associate mix), and what are standard billing rates? Do you offer fixed-fee options for plan document work, committee training, or compliance reviews? What is your approach to fiduciary governance (IPS reviews, fee benchmarking support, vendor oversight)? How do you handle urgent matters (DOL inquiries, litigation holds, subpoena response timelines)? Ultimately, Ice Miller vs Faegre Drinker is less about plan type coverage—both support 401(k), 403(b), and pensions—and more about which team’s style aligns with your risk profile: broad-based ongoing counsel and multi-office reach, or a litigation-forward ERISA posture built for disputes and investigations.