Human Interest vs Vanguard

Compare Human Interest and The Vanguard Group, Inc. side by side.

CategoryHuman InterestThe Vanguard Group, Inc.
Year Founded2,0151,975
Employees77120,000
HeadquartersSan Francisco, CAMalvern, PA
Websitehumaninterest.com/workplace.vanguard.com/home
Latest Client Statistics40,000 clients · $8.1B AUM1,400 clients · $523.0B AUM
ServicesRecordkeeping, 3(16) Plan Administrator, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(38) Investment Manager, 3(21) Investment Advisor, Participant Investment AdvicePlan Design Consulting, Compliance Services, Recordkeeping
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Solo 401(k)SEP IRA, 401(k)
AccreditationsRIA—
Published PricingComplete: $160 base fee, $7/employee
Concierge: $200 base fee, $9/employee
Essentials: $120 base fee, $5/employee
—
LocationsSan Francisco, CA, Lindon, UTMalvern, PA

Comparison Details

Human Interest vs Vanguard: Which retirement plan administrator fits your organization? Human Interest and The Vanguard Group both support employer-sponsored retirement plans, but they’re built for different sponsor profiles. Human Interest is a modern, tech-forward administrator focused on small and mid-sized businesses that want streamlined setup, payroll connectivity, and bundled fiduciary support. Vanguard is a legacy, large-scale retirement provider known for a low-cost investment philosophy and broad institutional capabilities—often appealing to sponsors prioritizing investment lineup strength and established infrastructure. Company size, focus, and typical plan fit Human Interest (founded 2015; ~771 employees) emphasizes ease of administration for growing businesses. It reports serving 40,000+ businesses with approximately $8.1B in 401(k) assets and ~ 792,873 participants (2026 data). Vanguard (founded 1975; ~20,000 employees) is one of the largest names in retirement. Client stats show ~ 1,400 401(k) clients with about $2.55T in 401(k) assets and ~ 4.8M participants (2024 data), highlighting a far larger asset and participant footprint. How to interpret this: If you want a provider optimized for SMB workflows and fast implementation, Human Interest is purpose-built for that. If you want a provider with massive scale and a brand strongly associated with low-cost investing, Vanguard stands out. Plans supported Human Interest: 401(k), 403(b), and solo(k) . Vanguard: 401(k) and SEP IRA . Nonprofits evaluating a 403(b) or owner-only businesses considering a solo 401(k) may find Human Interest a closer fit based on plan type support. Employers considering a SEP IRA option may lean Vanguard. Services and fiduciary support Both providers offer core administration capabilities like recordkeeping , compliance , and plan design . Human Interest also lists additional fiduciary and participant support services that can reduce sponsor workload: Human Interest: recordkeeping, compliance, plan design, 3(38) investment management, 3(21) fiduciary support, participant advice . Vanguard: recordkeeping, compliance, plan design, with a strong emphasis on participant outcomes and access to low-cost funds and ETFs. If your committee wants to offload more investment-related fiduciary responsibility, Human Interest’s 3(38)/3(21) options may be a deciding factor. If your priority is aligning the plan around a low-cost investment lineup and established retirement servicing model, Vanguard’s positioning may be compelling. Technology and payroll integrations Human Interest differentiates with extensive payroll connectivity—advertising integrations with 500+ payroll providers —which can reduce manual contribution work and improve ongoing administration. Vanguard also invests heavily in technology, but its differentiation is typically less about “plug-and-play” payroll breadth and more about large-provider servicing, plan sponsor support models, and investment access. Pricing transparency Human Interest publishes clear, plan-level pricing tiers, which is helpful for budget forecasting: Essentials: $120/month + $5/employee/month Complete: $160/month + $7/employee/month Concierge: $200/month + $9/employee/month Vanguard pricing is not provided in the data here and is often structured based on plan size and service configuration. For sponsors who value an upfront, easy-to-compare fee schedule, Human Interest may be simpler to evaluate early in the buying process. Notable differentiators Human Interest: (k)ickstart® participant incentive (3% cashback) and Audit Relief messaging aimed at reducing potential audit costs. Vanguard: client-owned structure and brand leadership in low-cost index investing, with broad access to Vanguard funds and ETFs. How to choose between Human Interest and Vanguard Choose Human Interest if you want SMB-friendly onboarding, broad payroll integrations, transparent tiered pricing, and optional 3(38)/3(21) fiduciary services. Choose Vanguard if investment philosophy and large-scale retirement infrastructure are top priorities, and you’re comfortable evaluating pricing through a tailored quote process. Ultimately, the best administrator depends on your plan’s complexity, desired fiduciary delegation, payroll environment, and how much you value published pricing versus institutional scale.