| Category | Human Interest | Sharebuilder 401k |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 2,015 | 2,005 |
| Employees | 771 | 51 |
| Headquarters | San Francisco, CA | Seattle, WA |
| Website | humaninterest.com/ | sharebuilder401k.com/ |
| Latest Client Statistics | 40,000 clients · $8.1B AUM | 6,500 clients · $2.0B AUM |
| Services | Recordkeeping, 3(16) Plan Administrator, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(38) Investment Manager, 3(21) Investment Advisor, Participant Investment Advice | Participant Investment Advice, Recordkeeping, 3(38) Investment Manager, Plan Design Consulting |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), Solo 401(k) | 401(k), Solo 401(k) |
| Accreditations | RIA | — |
| Published Pricing | Complete: $160 base fee, $7/employee Concierge: $200 base fee, $9/employee Essentials: $120 base fee, $5/employee | — |
| Locations | San Francisco, CA, Lindon, UT | Seattle, WA |
Comparison Details
Human Interest vs ShareBuilder 401k: Which 401(k) Administrator Fits Your Business? Choosing between Human Interest and ShareBuilder 401k often comes down to how you want your retirement plan to run day to day: a highly automated, payroll-integrated platform with transparent tiered fees (Human Interest) versus a lean, investment-led provider known for low-cost, index/ETF-oriented lineups and 3(38) management (ShareBuilder 401k). Both support small and mid-sized employers, but they differ in scale, plan breadth, and operational approach. Company size, footprint, and experience Human Interest (founded 2015) is a larger fintech administrator with ~ 728 employees and reported scale of ~ 37,353 401(k) clients, ~ 705,381 participants, and about $7.76B in AUM (2025 data). ShareBuilder 401k (founded 2005) is more established by founding date but smaller operationally (~ 51 employees ), serving ~ 6,500 businesses, ~ 150,000 participants, and about $2.0B in AUM (2026 data). If you value a larger servicing organization and broad operational infrastructure, Human Interest may stand out. If you prefer a more specialized provider with an investment-advisor identity, ShareBuilder can be compelling. Plans supported: 401(k), 403(b), and Solo(k) Human Interest supports 401(k), 403(b), and Solo(k) , which can be important for nonprofits (403(b)) or owners who want a solo plan option. ShareBuilder 401k supports 401(k) and Solo(k) , focusing primarily on small businesses and self-employed individuals. Services and fiduciary support (3(38), advice, and compliance) Both administrators cover core needs like recordkeeping and participant support, but the mix differs: Human Interest services: recordkeeping, compliance, 3(21) fiduciary support, participant advice, and 3(38) investment management. ShareBuilder 401k services: plan design, recordkeeping, participant advice, and 3(38) investment management (noted as an SEC-registered investment advisor). If you want flexibility between 3(21) and 3(38) models—or anticipate heavier compliance support—Human Interest provides multiple fiduciary configurations. If you specifically want a provider positioned around delegated investment management (3(38)) and an investment committee structure, ShareBuilder’s model may align well. Pricing transparency and what you’ll likely pay Human Interest publishes clear tiered pricing, which helps employers estimate costs upfront: Essentials: $120/month + $5 per employee/month Complete: $160/month + $7 per employee/month Concierge: $200/month + $9 per employee/month ShareBuilder 401k does not list pricing in the provided data. They are widely positioned as “low-cost” with digital quoting and small-business-friendly monthly pricing, but you’ll typically confirm exact fees through a quote based on employee count, desired fiduciary services, and investment lineup. Technology and payroll integrations Human Interest is known for deep operational automation, including payroll integrations with 500+ providers , which can reduce manual contribution processing and improve ongoing administration. ShareBuilder emphasizes simplicity and digital setup/quoting, with an investment lineup approach that has historically highlighted index-based and ETF-focused options. Notable differentiators Human Interest: features like (k)ickstart® (a 3% cashback incentive) and Audit Relief positioned to potentially offset annual plan audit costs. ShareBuilder 401k: positioning as a pioneer in index-based 401(k)s , all-ETF rosters , and an advisor-led 3(38) investment management approach. Which provider is better for you? Choose Human Interest if you want published pricing , broad payroll integration , support for 403(b) , and a large-scale platform built to streamline administration. Choose ShareBuilder 401k if you want a provider that leans into investment management (3(38)) , an index/ETF-oriented philosophy, and a small-business-first experience with guided support. Next step: request a formal proposal from each using your employee count, payroll provider, and desired fiduciary model (3(21) vs 3(38)) to compare total plan cost, investment expenses, and service scope apples-to-apples.