| Category | Human Interest | John Hancock |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 2,015 | 1,863 |
| Employees | 771 | 4,000 |
| Headquarters | San Francisco, CA | Boston, MA |
| Website | humaninterest.com/ | johnhancock.com/plan-sponsors.html |
| Latest Client Statistics | 40,000 clients · $8.1B AUM | 54,358 clients · $253.0B AUM |
| Services | Recordkeeping, 3(16) Plan Administrator, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(38) Investment Manager, 3(21) Investment Advisor, Participant Investment Advice | Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), Solo 401(k) | 401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP |
| Accreditations | RIA | — |
| Published Pricing | Complete: $160 base fee, $7/employee Concierge: $200 base fee, $9/employee Essentials: $120 base fee, $5/employee | — |
| Locations | San Francisco, CA, Lindon, UT | Boston, MA, Westwood, MA, Valhalla, NY, Boston, MA, Boston, MA |
Comparison Details
Human Interest vs John Hancock: Which retirement plan administrator fits your organization? Human Interest and John Hancock both support retirement plan administration, but they’re built for different sponsor profiles. Human Interest is a modern, tech-forward provider founded in 2015 and focused on making 401(k) and 403(b) plans simple and affordable for small and mid-sized businesses. John Hancock, founded in 1863 and part of Manulife, is a long-established financial services brand offering a broader retirement platform and a consultative service model for a wide range of plan sponsors. Plan types supported Human Interest: 401(k), 403(b), and solo 401(k) —a strong fit for startups, small businesses, and owner-only plans. John Hancock: supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP , and more—better for organizations needing multiple plan types or complex benefit structures. If your needs extend beyond a standard 401(k)/403(b)—for example, a 457(b) arrangement or defined benefit plan—John Hancock’s breadth is a key differentiator. Pricing transparency and predictability One of the clearest differences is pricing visibility. Human Interest pricing (published tiers): Essentials: $120/month + $5/employee/month Complete: $160/month + $7/employee/month Concierge: $200/month + $9/employee/month John Hancock: pricing is typically quote-based and varies by plan design, investments, and service model. For sponsors who want straightforward budgeting and quick comparisons, Human Interest’s transparent monthly fees can be easier to evaluate. For larger or more customized plans, John Hancock’s proposal-based approach may better reflect plan complexity and negotiated economics. Technology, payroll integrations, and day-to-day admin Human Interest differentiates with automation designed to reduce manual work. They highlight payroll integrations with 500+ providers , which can streamline contributions, eligibility, and ongoing administration—especially valuable for lean HR teams. John Hancock emphasizes a consultative, hands-on service approach with reporting and tools for financial wellness. Sponsors that prioritize a traditional service model and a large-provider ecosystem may prefer John Hancock’s structure, particularly when multiple stakeholders (consultants, financial representatives) are involved. Fiduciary support and services Human Interest services: recordkeeping, compliance, plan design, participant advice, and fiduciary support including 3(21) and 3(38) services. John Hancock services: recordkeeping, compliance, and plan design, with an emphasis on fiduciary expertise and sponsor support through partners and dedicated contacts. If you’re specifically looking to delegate investment discretion through a 3(38) arrangement, Human Interest’s listed fiduciary service options are a notable comparison point. Scale, market focus, and track record Human Interest: ~ 771 employees , founded 2015, and reports serving 40,000+ businesses . Client stats show approximately $8.1B AUM and 792,873 participants (401(k), 2026). John Hancock: ~ 4,000 employees , founded 1863, and supports retirement needs for millions of Americans across its broader organization—often appealing to sponsors seeking a long-tenured brand and extensive resources. Unique features to consider Human Interest: features like (k)ickstart® (3% cashback incentive) and Audit Relief (positioned to potentially save $10,000+ on annual plan audits) can be compelling for cost-conscious SMBs and growing companies approaching audit thresholds. John Hancock: known for robust communications, wellness tools, and a broad investment and retirement services platform aligned with larger sponsor expectations. Which is better for your plan? Choose Human Interest if you want transparent pricing, strong payroll automation, SMB-friendly administration, and optional 3(21)/3(38) fiduciary support. Choose John Hancock if you need broader plan types (like 457 or defined benefit), a consultative service model, and the depth of a long-established retirement and financial services organization. For many sponsors, the decision comes down to simplicity and automation (Human Interest) versus breadth and traditional enterprise servicing (John Hancock).