| Category | Gusto | Vestwell |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | — | 2,016 |
| Employees | — | 350 |
| Headquarters | — | New York City, NY |
| Website | gusto.com/product/benefits/financial/401k-plans | vestwell.com/ |
| Latest Client Statistics | 40,000 clients · $10.0B AUM | 12,086 clients · $34.9B AUM |
| Latest Audit Statistics | — | — |
| Services | — | Compliance Services, 3(16) Plan Administrator, 3(38) Investment Manager, Recordkeeping, 3(21) Investment Advisor |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), Solo 401(k), SIMPLE IRA | 401(k), 403(b), Solo 401(k) |
| Accreditations | — | — |
| Published Pricing | — | Plus: $125 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Starter(k): $39 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Workplace: $80 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee |
| Locations | — | New York City, NY |
Comparison Details
Gusto vs Vestwell: which retirement plan administrator fits your business? Gusto and Vestwell both support modern, tech-forward retirement plans, but they approach administration differently. Gusto is best known as an all-in-one payroll and HR platform that offers an integrated 401(k) experience through a partner relationship with Guideline. Vestwell, by contrast, is built around a dedicated digital recordkeeping platform and offers optional fiduciary outsourcing (3(16), 3(21), and 3(38)) alongside a broader set of workplace savings programs. At-a-glance differences Core focus: Gusto combines payroll/HR/benefits with retirement plan access; Vestwell is a retirement recordkeeper/administrator with advisor and employer tooling. Plan types supported: Gusto supports 401(k), Solo(k), and SIMPLE IRA; Vestwell supports 401(k), 403(b), Solo(k), and Starter(k). Fiduciary services: Vestwell offers 3(16), 3(21), and 3(38) services; Gusto’s retirement offering is delivered via its partnership model (with setup and compliance assistance) rather than being positioned as an in-house fiduciary suite. Reported scale: Gusto/Guideline: 40,000 businesses, ~700,000 participants, and $10B AUM (client stats provided). Vestwell: 12,086 clients and $34.9B AUM (as of 2025, per provided stats). Plan support and who each is best for Gusto If your priority is minimizing admin across payroll, HR, and benefits, Gusto’s integrated experience can be compelling—especially for small and medium-sized businesses already running payroll on Gusto. Gusto supports 401(k) , Solo(k) , and SIMPLE IRA options, and emphasizes automation, streamlined setup, and help with filings. It also highlights support for staying compliant with state retirement mandates and features like generating automatic tax credit forms to help employers capture eligible credits. Vestwell Vestwell is often a strong fit for organizations that want a dedicated retirement platform with flexibility across plan designs and the option to outsource fiduciary responsibilities. In addition to 401(k) and Solo(k) , Vestwell supports 403(b) plans (important for nonprofits and certain education-related employers) and a Starter(k) tier for simpler entry-level coverage. Beyond retirement, Vestwell also supports specialty savings and financial wellness programs such as 529 plans , emergency savings , ABLE accounts , and student loan repayment benefits . Pricing transparency Pricing is one of the clearest differentiators in this comparison based on available data. Vestwell pricing (published): Starter(k): $39/month + $8 per employee/month , $0 setup Workplace: $80/month + $8 per employee/month , $0 setup Plus: $125/month + $8 per employee/month , $0 setup Gusto pricing: Not provided in the data above for the retirement plan component. If you’re comparing total cost, request a full quote that includes plan administration, recordkeeping, and any investment-related expenses—especially if you’re bundling with payroll/HR. Administration model, integrations, and compliance Gusto’s advantage is the embedded workflow : payroll, onboarding, and benefits live in one system, and the retirement plan experience is designed to reduce manual steps for small teams. Vestwell’s advantage is the retirement-first platform with payroll integrations , multilingual support, and a menu of fiduciary and compliance services that can reduce sponsor burden when you want formal outsourcing. How to choose between Gusto and Vestwell Choose Gusto if you want retirement benefits tightly integrated with payroll/HR and prefer a simplified, automated experience for a small-to-midsize business. Choose Vestwell if you need 403(b) support, want optional 3(16)/3(21)/3(38) fiduciary services, or prefer a dedicated recordkeeping platform with transparent base pricing. For the final decision, compare (1) total all-in fees, (2) fiduciary responsibility coverage, (3) payroll integration depth for your specific payroll provider, and (4) the plan types and add-on savings programs your workforce will actually use.