| Category | Guideline, Inc. | Voya Financial |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 2,015 | — |
| Employees | 350 | 9,000 |
| Headquarters | Burlingame, CA | New York City, NY |
| Website | guideline.com/ | voya.com/ |
| Latest Client Statistics | 60,000 clients · $15.0B AUM | 65,135 clients · $729.0B AUM |
| Services | Fiduciary Audit Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(16) Plan Administrator, Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, Participant Investment Advice, 3(38) Investment Manager | Recordkeeping, Compliance Services |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), Solo 401(k), SEP IRA | 401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP |
| Accreditations | — | — |
| Published Pricing | Core: $89 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Enterprise: $149 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Starter: $39 base fee, $4/employee, $0 setup fee | — |
| Locations | Burlingame, CA | New York City, NY |
Comparison Details
Guideline vs Voya Financial: Which retirement plan administrator fits your organization? Guideline, Inc. and Voya Financial both support retirement plan administration and recordkeeping, but they’re built for different buyer profiles. Guideline is a modern, tech-first 401(k) platform designed to make setup and ongoing administration straightforward for small and mid-sized employers. Voya is a large, diversified financial services provider with broad plan coverage and infrastructure that often appeals to larger employers and institutions across corporate, nonprofit, education, healthcare, and government segments. Company size, focus, and approach Guideline (founded 2015; ~350 employees; HQ: Burlingame, CA): A fintech retirement provider focused on simplifying employer administration with an integrated platform for plan administration, investment management, and payroll synchronization. Voya Financial (~9,000 employees; HQ: New York City, NY): A major financial services organization offering workplace solutions and retirement services at scale, typically with a more traditional enterprise/provider model. If you value a streamlined, software-driven experience and transparent packaged pricing, Guideline tends to stand out. If you need a provider with extensive institutional experience and coverage across many plan types, Voya often fits that brief. Plan types supported Guideline: 401(k), Solo 401(k), SEP IRA Voya: 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP, and broader “all” plan coverage This is one of the clearest differences. Guideline is primarily optimized for 401(k)-centric small business retirement plans, while Voya supports a wider range of plan structures—including tax-exempt and governmental plan types (403(b)/457) and more complex arrangements like defined benefit plans and ESOPs. Services and fiduciary support Beyond basic administration, employers often compare providers based on fiduciary outsourcing and participant support. Guideline services: recordkeeping, compliance, plan design, 3(16) administrative fiduciary support, 3(38) investment fiduciary services, participant advice, and fiduciary/audit-related support. Voya services (listed): recordkeeping and compliance. Guideline’s bundled fiduciary options (3(16) and 3(38)) can be attractive to employers that want to reduce internal workload and shift certain fiduciary responsibilities. Voya may still offer additional capabilities in practice depending on plan size and channel, but based on the provided service list, Guideline is positioned as the more “outsourced fiduciary + admin” package. Pricing transparency Pricing can be a deciding factor—especially for startups and growing teams. Guideline published tiers: Starter: $39/mo base + $4/employee/mo , $0 setup Core: $89/mo base + $8/employee/mo , $0 setup Enterprise: $149/mo base + $8/employee/mo , $0 setup Voya: pricing not provided (often quote-based depending on plan type, size, and services). If you want clear, predictable admin costs without a custom proposal, Guideline has an advantage. If your plan is complex (e.g., 403(b), 457, defined benefit) or requires tailored services, a quote-based model like Voya’s may be more typical. Technology and payroll integration Guideline emphasizes a seamless, technology-driven experience, including payroll synchronization and well-known integration with Gusto . This can reduce manual work, improve contribution accuracy, and streamline ongoing compliance tasks. Voya offers broad workplace solutions and resources, but the experience may vary more by plan segment and implementation approach. Scale and market presence Guideline (DB stats): ~ 60,000 401(k) clients, ~ $15B AUM, ~ 500,000 participants (2026). Voya (DB stats sample): 403(b) entry shows 135 clients and 5 participants (2025), with other plan types listed but without totals. Guideline’s reported 401(k) footprint signals strong adoption among small and mid-sized employers. Voya’s overall scale is substantial as a company, but the provided plan-level stats are incomplete, so a direct like-for-like comparison on administered assets/participants isn’t available here. Which should you choose? Choose Guideline if you want a modern 401(k) administrator with transparent pricing, strong payroll integration, and built-in 3(16)/3(38) fiduciary services for a small-to-midsize business. Choose Voya Financial if you need broad plan-type support (403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP) or you’re an institution/large employer looking for a large-provider ecosystem and traditional retirement services infrastructure. For many employers, the decision comes down to plan complexity and desired admin experience: Guideline is optimized for simplicity and automation, while Voya is positioned for breadth and institutional coverage.