| Category | Guideline, Inc. | John Hancock |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 2,015 | 1,863 |
| Employees | 350 | 4,000 |
| Headquarters | Burlingame, CA | Boston, MA |
| Website | guideline.com/ | johnhancock.com/plan-sponsors.html |
| Latest Client Statistics | 60,000 clients · $15.0B AUM | 54,358 clients · $253.0B AUM |
| Services | Fiduciary Audit Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(16) Plan Administrator, Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, Participant Investment Advice, 3(38) Investment Manager | Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), Solo 401(k), SEP IRA | 401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP |
| Accreditations | — | — |
| Published Pricing | Core: $89 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Enterprise: $149 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Starter: $39 base fee, $4/employee, $0 setup fee | — |
| Locations | Burlingame, CA | Boston, MA, Westwood, MA, Valhalla, NY, Boston, MA, Boston, MA |
Comparison Details
Guideline vs John Hancock: Which retirement plan administrator fits your business? Guideline, Inc. and John Hancock Retirement Plan Services both support employers with retirement plan administration and recordkeeping, but they’re built for different buyer profiles. Guideline is a modern fintech administrator focused on streamlined, tech-enabled 401(k) delivery for small and midsize businesses. John Hancock is a long-established financial services institution offering broader retirement plan capabilities and a more consultative, relationship-driven model for sponsors who want a traditional provider with extensive resources. At-a-glance differences Company profile: Guideline (founded 2015, ~350 employees) vs John Hancock (founded 1863, ~4,000 employees). Plan breadth: Guideline supports 401(k), Solo 401(k), SEP IRA ; John Hancock supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP and more. Service model: Guideline emphasizes automation + payroll sync ; John Hancock emphasizes advisor/consultant partnerships and sponsor support. Published pricing: Guideline lists transparent tiers; John Hancock pricing is typically custom/quote-based. Plan types and sponsor complexity Guideline: best for straightforward 401(k) administration Guideline is purpose-built around defined contribution plans—especially the core needs of small businesses launching or modernizing a 401(k). If you want a simplified setup, ongoing compliance support, and a consistent participant experience without heavy customization, Guideline’s model aligns well. Guideline also supports Solo 401(k) and SEP IRA options, which can be attractive for owner-only businesses or self-employed individuals. John Hancock: best for multi-plan and more complex needs John Hancock supports a wider range of plan types, including 403(b) , 457 , defined benefit , and ESOP arrangements. That breadth matters if you’re a nonprofit, governmental entity, or employer with legacy plan structures, multiple divisions, or a need to coordinate across different benefit programs. Sponsors seeking a provider with long-standing retirement infrastructure may prefer John Hancock’s scale and established processes. Services and fiduciary support Guideline’s integrated fiduciary services Guideline positions itself as an integrated platform combining administration, recordkeeping, and investment management. Notably, it offers 3(38) investment manager services and 3(16) administrative fiduciary support, plus participant advice, compliance, and plan design. For employers looking to reduce internal workload and shift certain fiduciary responsibilities, these services can be a key differentiator. John Hancock’s sponsor support and reporting John Hancock offers core retirement plan services such as plan design, compliance, and recordkeeping, delivered through a consultative approach that often includes financial professionals and dedicated support teams. Sponsors that value hands-on guidance, established communications, and robust plan reporting may find John Hancock’s model a better cultural fit than a primarily self-serve platform. Pricing transparency and expected costs Guideline pricing (published tiers) Guideline provides clear, tiered pricing with $0 setup fees in the plans listed: Starter: $39/month base + $4/employee/month Core: $89/month base + $8/employee/month Enterprise: $149/month base + $8/employee/month This transparency can make budgeting and comparisons easier—especially for small employers evaluating total plan administration costs. John Hancock pricing (typically quote-based) John Hancock does not publish standard pricing in the provided data. In practice, large providers often price based on plan size, service bundle, investment lineup, and distribution/advisor structure. If you want a customized proposal—especially for larger or more complex plans—John Hancock may be well-suited, but you should expect a sales/consultative quoting process. Scale, adoption, and track record Guideline reports a substantial footprint in the small-business 401(k) market, with approximately 60,000 401(k) plans , $15B in AUM , and 500,000 participants (2026 data provided). John Hancock brings a far longer operating history and broad financial services presence, which can be reassuring for sponsors prioritizing institutional longevity and extensive operational capacity. How to choose between Guideline and John Hancock Choose Guideline if you want transparent pricing , a tech-forward experience , payroll-oriented efficiencies, and integrated 3(16)/3(38) fiduciary options for a primarily 401(k)-focused program. Choose John Hancock if you need broader plan types (403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP), prefer a relationship-driven model , or want a provider with a long-standing presence and consultative support structure. For the best decision, request a proposal and confirm what’s included in administration, compliance, investment oversight, participant support, and any fiduciary services—then compare total cost and service scope side by side.