| Category | Grant Thornton LLP | BDO USA P.C. |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,924 | 1,910 |
| Employees | — | — |
| Headquarters | Oakbrook Terrace, IL | Philadelphia, PA |
| Website | grantthornton.com/ | bdo.com/locations/bdo-philadelphia-office |
| Latest Audit Statistics | 798 plans audited · $403.0B AUM | 1,274 plans audited · $454.9B AUM |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare | 401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare |
| Accreditations | AICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member | AICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC |
| Published Pricing | — | — |
| Locations | Oakbrook Terrace, IL | Philadelphia, PA |
Comparison Details
Grant Thornton vs BDO USA P.C. for Employee Benefit Plan Audits Choosing an employee benefit plan auditor is a high-stakes decision—your CPA firm impacts audit quality, timelines, sponsor workload, and how smoothly you navigate DOL and ERISA requirements. Both Grant Thornton LLP and BDO USA P.C. are large, nationally recognized accounting firms offering assurance, tax, and advisory services, and both support a wide range of plan audits including 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit , ESOP , and health & welfare plans. At-a-glance comparison Founded: Grant Thornton (1924) vs BDO (1910) Plan types supported: Both support 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, and health & welfare Headquarters: Grant Thornton: Oakbrook Terrace, IL (Chicago area); BDO: U.S. offices nationwide (example location: Philadelphia, PA) Core services: Both provide Audit & Assurance, Tax, and Advisory services Scale and 401(k) audit volume (2024) One practical differentiator is audit scale . Larger benefit plan audit practices may offer deeper bench strength for complex plans, specialist review, and continuity if staffing changes occur. BDO USA P.C.: 1,274 401(k) plans audited in 2024, representing about $454.9B in audited 401(k) AUM. Grant Thornton LLP: 798 401(k) plans audited in 2024, representing about $403.0B in audited 401(k) AUM. What this can mean for sponsors: If you want a firm with very high 401(k) audit throughput, BDO shows higher plan count in the available 2024 data. Grant Thornton still reflects substantial scale and may be a strong fit for sponsors prioritizing a large-firm approach with a slightly different industry footprint and team structure. Industry focus and firm profile Grant Thornton LLP Grant Thornton is widely recognized as one of the largest CPA firms in the U.S., with a stated focus on delivering data-driven insights and serving dynamic organizations. The firm highlights industry strength in areas such as Financial Services , Health Sciences , and Manufacturing , which can matter if your plan sponsor has complex operational or regulatory considerations tied to those sectors. BDO USA P.C. BDO is a long-established professional services firm with broad industry coverage, often emphasizing sectors such as healthcare , life sciences , manufacturing & distribution , real estate , and technology . With a wide office footprint (including locations like Philadelphia ), BDO can be attractive for sponsors looking for local accessibility paired with national resources. How to choose between Grant Thornton and BDO Choose based on plan complexity: ESOPs, defined benefit plans, and large 401(k)s with multiple payrolls/entities may benefit from teams that regularly handle similar audits. Ask about the engagement team: Who is the day-to-day manager, what is partner involvement, and what is the turnover/continuity plan? Confirm ERISA audit approach: Discuss timelines, PBC (prepared-by-client) expectations, and how they coordinate with your recordkeeper/TPA. Evaluate responsiveness and project management: For many sponsors, on-time delivery and clear request lists matter as much as brand name. Both Grant Thornton and BDO are credible, large-firm options for ERISA employee benefit plan audits . If you value the highest observed 2024 401(k) audit volume in this comparison, BDO stands out. If you want a top-tier national firm with strong industry positioning and significant 401(k) audit scale, Grant Thornton remains a compelling contender—especially when the proposed engagement team aligns closely with your plan’s needs.