| Category | Fidelity Investments | TIAA |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,949 | 1,918 |
| Employees | 50,000 | — |
| Headquarters | Boston, MA | New York, NY |
| Website | fidelityworkplace.com/ | tiaa.org/ |
| Latest Client Statistics | 37,255 clients · $4.4T AUM | 0 clients · $600.0B AUM |
| Services | Recordkeeping | — |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit | 401(k), 403(b), 457 |
| Accreditations | — | — |
| Published Pricing | Fidelity Advantage 401(k): $100 base fee, $8.33/employee, $500 setup fee | — |
| Locations | Boston, MA | Charlotte, NC, Charlotte, NC, New York, NY, Kansas City, MO |
Comparison Details
Fidelity vs TIAA: which retirement plan administrator fits your organization? Choosing between Fidelity Investments and TIAA often comes down to your organization type (corporate vs. nonprofit/education/public sector), the plan(s) you sponsor, and whether you value transparent packaged pricing or a more bespoke, institution-oriented approach. Both are major names in workplace retirement, but they tend to win in different scenarios. At-a-glance comparison Headquarters: Fidelity (Boston, MA) vs. TIAA (New York, NY) Plan types supported: Fidelity supports 401(k), 403(b), and defined benefit ; TIAA supports 401(k), 403(b), and 457 Scale signals: Fidelity lists ~50,000 employees and large participant counts across multiple plan types; TIAA highlights serving institutions (notably higher ed, medical, research, government) Pricing visibility: Fidelity provides packaged pricing for a 401(k) product; TIAA pricing is typically quote-based (not published here) Plan support and “best fit” by organization type Fidelity: broad workplace coverage plus defined benefit Fidelity supports 401(k) and 403(b) plans and also lists support for defined benefit plans. If your organization needs a provider that can align administration across multiple retirement programs—including a pension-style plan—Fidelity may be a strong contender. Fidelity’s workplace offering is positioned around recordkeeping and large-plan operational infrastructure. TIAA: especially common in 403(b) and 457 environments TIAA is historically associated with the academic, research, medical, cultural, and governmental sectors. It supports 403(b) and 457 plans—two plan types frequently used by nonprofits and public employers. TIAA also emphasizes retirement income solutions, including the well-known TIAA Traditional annuity for participants seeking guaranteed income features. Pricing and cost structure Fidelity pricing example (published) Fidelity lists pricing for Fidelity Advantage 401(k) : Base fee: $100 Per-employee fee: $8.33 Setup fee: $500 This type of packaged pricing can be helpful for budgeting and comparing administrators—especially for small to mid-sized employers that want clear baseline costs. TIAA pricing (typically custom) TIAA pricing isn’t provided in the data above, which is common for institution-focused retirement providers. Costs may vary based on plan size, complexity, investment lineup, legacy contracts, and whether retirement income features (like annuity options) are central to the plan design. Scale, capabilities, and participant experience Fidelity: large recordkeeping footprint Fidelity’s scale is reflected in the available client statistics, including substantial participant counts across 403(b) and defined benefit plans. Large-scale recordkeepers often invest heavily in digital experiences, integrations, cybersecurity, and standardized operational processes—important considerations for committees that prioritize reliability and reporting. TIAA: mission-driven retirement focus Founded in 1918 , TIAA positions itself as a mission-driven organization with deep roots in retirement outcomes, participant education, and guidance. Employers that want a provider known for retirement income orientation and strong presence in higher education and nonprofit sectors often shortlist TIAA for that reason. How to decide between Fidelity and TIAA Choose Fidelity if you want published 401(k) pricing , strong recordkeeping , and potential alignment across multiple plan types including defined benefit . Choose TIAA if you’re in higher ed/nonprofit/public sector and want a provider known for 403(b)/457 environments and retirement income solutions like TIAA Traditional. Next steps: confirm plan type compatibility (especially DB vs. 457 needs), request a fee disclosure/quote, and compare service models (education, advice availability, payroll integrations, and participant support) before making a final administrator selection.