Fidelity vs Principal

Compare Fidelity Investments and Principal Financial Group, Inc. side by side.

CategoryFidelity InvestmentsPrincipal Financial Group, Inc.
Year Founded1,9491,879
Employees50,00020,000
HeadquartersBoston, MADes Moines, IA
Websitefidelityworkplace.com/principal.com/individuals/invest-retire/retirement-plans/401k-403b-retirement-plans
Latest Client Statistics37,255 clients · $4.4T AUM11,086 clients · $540.4B AUM
Latest Audit Statistics——
ServicesRecordkeepingCompliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, Recordkeeping, Participant Investment Advice
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP
Accreditations——
Published PricingFidelity Advantage 401(k): $100 base fee, $8.33/employee, $500 setup fee—
LocationsBoston, MADes Moines, IA

Comparison Details

Fidelity vs Principal: comparing retirement plan administrators Fidelity Investments and Principal Financial Group, Inc. are both major retirement plan administrators (recordkeepers) that support employer-sponsored retirement plans. While each can serve as a strong long-term partner for plan operations, they differ in service breadth, plan menu coverage, and pricing transparency—factors that matter when you’re selecting a provider for a 401(k), 403(b), 457, or defined benefit plan. Company scale and footprint Fidelity Investments is a large multinational financial services firm headquartered in Boston, MA with approximately 50,000 employees . Its scale is reflected in participant volumes across multiple plan segments, including substantial 403(b) and defined benefit participant counts in available 2025 stats. Principal Financial Group (founded 1879 ) is headquartered in Des Moines, IA with approximately 20,000 employees . Principal pairs retirement plan administration with a long-standing insurance and benefits business, which can be attractive for employers seeking more of a bundled workplace benefits relationship. Plans supported: where each provider fits best Both providers support core employer retirement plans, but Principal shows broader plan-type coverage in the data provided. Fidelity plans supported: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit Principal plans supported: 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP What this means: If you need an ESOP or want a single administrator that clearly supports a wider set of plan types (including 457), Principal may have an edge on breadth. If your focus is a mainstream 401(k) or 403(b) with a large, well-known recordkeeper, Fidelity is often considered a top-tier option. Services and consulting: recordkeeping vs broader support Fidelity (services listed): recordkeeping Principal (services listed): recordkeeping, compliance , participant advice , plan design Decision tip: If your internal team wants a provider that can help more directly with plan design decisions , compliance support , and participant guidance , Principal is positioned as a more consultative, end-to-end administrator in the provided service set. If you already have a strong advisor/TPA structure and primarily need robust recordkeeping, Fidelity’s model may align well. Pricing transparency and what you can benchmark Pricing can vary by plan size, complexity, and service bundle, but transparency helps when you’re comparing administrators. Fidelity pricing (example product): Fidelity Advantage 401(k) shows a $100 base fee , $8.33 per employee , and a $500 setup fee . Principal pricing: not listed in the provided data, which may indicate quote-based pricing depending on plan design and service selections. How to use this: If you want a starting benchmark to model monthly admin costs, Fidelity’s published-style fee components can be easier to compare. If you expect a more customized bundle (e.g., compliance + participant advice + plan design), Principal may price based on the overall scope and employer profile. Client scale signals (from provided 2025 stats) Both providers show meaningful presence across plan types. Fidelity’s available stats show particularly large participant counts in 403(b) and defined benefit segments, while Principal’s stats show substantial defined benefit client counts and participation across segments. Which administrator should you choose? Choose Fidelity if you want a large, widely recognized recordkeeper and you value clear, benchmarkable pricing components for a 401(k) (and you have other partners covering plan design/compliance as needed). Choose Principal if you want a provider with broader listed services (compliance, plan design, participant advice) and broader plan-type support (including ESOP), potentially within a larger benefits/insurance relationship. For a final decision, request proposals from both using the same plan census and service checklist (plan type, eligibility, match, payroll cadence, compliance scope, participant education) so you can compare total cost, service model, and implementation timeline apples-to-apples.