# EisnerAmper vs PKF O&#39;Connor Davies
Source: https://planprovider.pro/compare/eisneramper-vs-pkf-oconnor-davies

> Compare EisnerAmper vs PKF O’Connor Davies for employee benefit plan audits: scale, experience, 401(k) volume, and service focus.

Compare EisnerAmper LLP and PKF O'Connor Davies, LLP side by side.

| Category|EisnerAmper LLP|PKF O'Connor Davies, LLP|

| Year Founded|1,965|1,891|

| Employees|4,000|1,000|

| Headquarters|Iselin, NJ|Harrison, NY|

| Website|eisneramper.com/|www.pkfod.com/|

| Latest Audit Statistics|598 plans audited · $98.5B AUM|554 plans audited · $53.0B AUM|

| Plans Supported|401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare|401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare|

| Accreditations|AICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member|AICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member|

| Published Pricing|—|—|

| Locations|Iselin, NJ|Harrison, NY|

## Comparison Details

EisnerAmper vs PKF O’Connor Davies: employee benefit plan audit comparison Choosing an employee benefit plan auditor is a high-stakes decision for plan sponsors and committees—especially when you’re facing ERISA audit requirements, complex plan operations, or heightened DOL scrutiny. Both EisnerAmper LLP and PKF O’Connor Davies, LLP are established CPA firms that audit a range of benefit plans, including 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit , ESOP , and health &amp; welfare plans. Below is a practical comparison to help you decide which auditor may be the better fit for your organization. Firm size, footprint, and resources EisnerAmper LLP (founded 1965 ) reports roughly 4,000 employees , offering a larger bench for specialized audit teams, technical consultation, and multi-office coverage. The firm highlights a risk-based audit approach and the use of advanced tools and technology to support quality and regulatory compliance. PKF O’Connor Davies, LLP (founded 1891 ) has about 1,000 employees and is headquartered in Harrison, NY . The firm emphasizes a relationship-centered approach and “digital agility,” with services spanning assurance, tax, advisory, and technology/cybersecurity. How this matters: Larger firms can be advantageous for sponsors with multiple locations, complex benefit offerings, or a need for deeper technical resources. A slightly smaller firm can still deliver top-tier audits while offering a more boutique-style engagement experience depending on team structure and partner involvement. 401(k) audit volume and audited assets (2024) Audit volume can be a useful proxy for an auditor’s familiarity with common plan issues (eligibility, contributions, payroll interfaces, SOC reports, and participant data). Based on available 2024 audit stats: EisnerAmper 401(k) audits: 598 plans audited; approximately $98.5B in audited 401(k) assets (AUM). PKF O’Connor Davies 401(k) audits: 554 plans audited; approximately $53.0B in audited 401(k) assets (AUM). What to infer: Both firms demonstrate substantial 401(k) audit experience. EisnerAmper shows a higher audited-asset figure and slightly higher plan count in the available dataset, which may be relevant if your plan has larger asset complexity, multiple investment options, or more intricate operational workflows. Service approach and differentiators EisnerAmper: Positions its audits as risk-based and standards-driven, with an emphasis on transparency, accuracy , and leveraging technology across assurance and advisory services. PKF O’Connor Davies: Highlights value creation and a relationship-led model , plus notable strength in technology &amp; cybersecurity —an important consideration if your plan sponsor is focused on data protection, vendor risk, and internal controls around payroll/HRIS integrations. Which auditor is a better fit? Choose EisnerAmper if you want a larger national-scale team, strong volume in 401(k) audits, and a firm that explicitly promotes a risk-based, technology-enabled audit methodology—often helpful for complex plan operations or larger audited asset bases. Choose PKF O’Connor Davies if you value a relationship-centered engagement model, want a firm recognized among top accounting firms, and see added benefit in integrated advisory capabilities such as technology and cybersecurity alongside the annual plan audit. Questions to ask both firms before selecting Who will be the day-to-day audit team, and how many ERISA audits do they personally complete each year? How do you handle SOC 1 report reliance, payroll-to-recordkeeper reconciliation, and eligibility testing documentation? What is your typical timeline and PBC (prepared-by-client) process, and what technology do you use to streamline requests? How do you support plan sponsors with emerging risks (cybersecurity, missing participants, operational errors, SECURE Act changes)? Ultimately, the best choice depends on your plan complexity, committee expectations, and the engagement style you prefer. Use the data points above—firm scale, 401(k) audit volume, and service emphasis—to shortlist the auditor that aligns with your risk profile and operational needs.

[View all provider comparisons on PlanProvider.Pro](https://planprovider.pro/compare)

&copy; 2026 PlanProvider.Pro
