Doeren Mayhew vs Caron Bletzer

Compare Doeren Mayhew Assurance and Caron Bletzer, PLLC side by side.

CategoryDoeren Mayhew AssuranceCaron Bletzer, PLLC
Year Founded2,0031,993
Employees550—
HeadquartersTroy, MIKingston, NH
Websitedoeren.com/caronbletzer.com/
Latest Audit Statistics407 plans audited · $22.7B AUM1,147 plans audited · $97.2B AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP
AccreditationsAICPA EBPAQC, AICPA MemberPCAOB Registered
Published Pricing——
LocationsTroy, MIKingston, NH

Comparison Details

Doeren Mayhew Assurance vs Caron Bletzer, PLLC: Employee Benefit Plan Audit Comparison Choosing an employee benefit plan (EBP) auditor often comes down to specialization, capacity, and experience with your plan type. Both Doeren Mayhew Assurance and Caron Bletzer, PLLC are established audit firms that support common retirement plan audits, but they differ meaningfully in focus and scale—especially for high-volume 401(k) audit work. Firm focus: full-service CPA firm vs EBP-audit specialist Doeren Mayhew Assurance (HQ: Troy, MI) is positioned as a strategic CPA firm providing a broad mix of audit, tax, and advisory services. This can be attractive for organizations that prefer an auditor that can coordinate across broader finance, tax, and business advisory needs beyond the plan audit. Caron Bletzer, PLLC (HQ: Kingston, NH) is focused exclusively on employee benefit plan audits . That specialization is a key differentiator for sponsors who want a firm built specifically around EBP audit methodology, EBP staff training, and audit process repeatability. The firm is also described as nationally recognized and ranked as the 14th largest EBP audit practice in the U.S. Scale and capacity: 401(k) audit volume and AUM audited One practical way to compare auditors is to look at recent audit throughput and the size of plans audited. Based on 2024 401(k) audit statistics: Doeren Mayhew Assurance : 407 401(k) plans audited; approximately $22.7B in 401(k) AUM audited (2024). Caron Bletzer, PLLC : 1,147 401(k) plans audited; approximately $97.2B in 401(k) AUM audited (2024). This indicates Caron Bletzer runs a significantly higher-volume 401(k) audit practice, which may appeal to plan sponsors looking for an auditor with deep repetition in common 401(k) audit areas (eligibility, contributions, distributions, participant data, and SOC report reliance). Doeren Mayhew’s lower—but still substantial—volume may appeal to sponsors who want strong EBP experience within a broader CPA/advisory platform. Plan types supported: where each firm may fit best Both firms support core retirement plan types, but Doeren Mayhew lists a slightly broader scope. Doeren Mayhew Assurance supports: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, and health & welfare plans. Caron Bletzer, PLLC supports: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, and ESOP plans. If your organization needs a health & welfare plan audit alongside retirement plan audits, Doeren Mayhew’s stated plan support may be a deciding factor. If your primary need is a retirement plan audit and you prefer a firm dedicated solely to EBP audits, Caron Bletzer’s specialization stands out. Company profile and footprint Doeren Mayhew Assurance : founded in 2003 , approximately 550 employees , with a long-standing brand history referenced as “over 90 years” of client service. Caron Bletzer, PLLC : founded in 1993 , employee count not provided, and markets itself as performing 1,200+ EBP audits annually . How to choose between Doeren Mayhew and Caron Bletzer Choose Caron Bletzer, PLLC if you want an EBP-audit-only firm with very high 401(k) audit volume and a practice built around dedicated benefit plan auditing. Choose Doeren Mayhew Assurance if you want a full-service CPA firm that can align your plan audit with broader accounting, tax, and advisory needs and you may also require health & welfare plan audit support. Next steps: confirm each firm’s experience with your specific plan features (e.g., ESOP complexities, DB actuarial coordination, 403(b) universal availability, multiple payroll feeds), expected audit timeline, engagement staffing model, and how they handle PBC requests and SOC report reliance.