Deloitte vs Ernst & Young

Compare Deloitte & Touche LLP and Ernst & Young LLP side by side.

CategoryDeloitte & Touche LLPErnst & Young LLP
Year Founded1,8451,989
Employees470,000—
HeadquartersChicago, ILNew York, NY
Websitedeloitte.com/us/en/offices/us-locations/chicago.htmley.com/
Latest Audit Statistics567 plans audited · $1.0T AUM638 plans audited · $1.0T AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare
AccreditationsAICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQCAICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member
Published Pricing——
LocationsChicago, ILNew York, NY

Comparison Details

Deloitte vs Ernst & Young (EY): Which Employee Benefit Plan Auditor Fits Your Plan? Choosing between Deloitte & Touche LLP and Ernst & Young LLP (EY) often comes down to your plan’s complexity, stakeholder expectations, and the level of global resources you want behind your annual employee benefit plan audit. Both firms support common ERISA plan audit needs across 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit , ESOP , and health & welfare plans, and both operate as major professional services networks with deep assurance capabilities. At-a-glance comparison Provider type: Large national/global audit and assurance firms Plan types supported (both): 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, health & welfare Founding: Deloitte (1845) vs EY (1989) Web presence: Deloitte Chicago office page vs EY global site (ey.com) Audit scale and 401(k) market activity If you’re evaluating auditors based on demonstrated 401(k) audit volume, both firms show significant activity. Based on the provided 2024 audit stats: EY (2024): 638 401(k) plans audited; approximately $1.006T in associated AUM Deloitte (2024): 567 401(k) plans audited; approximately $1.020T in associated AUM In other words, EY shows a higher count of 401(k) audits, while Deloitte shows slightly higher total AUM in the provided dataset. For plan sponsors, this can be a useful proxy for how frequently a firm engages with large and complex plans, though the “best” choice still depends on your service team, timeline, and plan-specific risk areas. Service model and capabilities Deloitte & Touche LLP Deloitte positions itself as a broad professional services firm with offerings that extend beyond audit into assurance, cyber, business process solutions, enterprise technology & performance, and human capital . For benefit plan audits, that breadth can matter if your audit intersects with: Complex payroll and HRIS ecosystems (controls, integrations, SOC reports) Cyber and technology risk considerations around participant data Operational transformation initiatives (recordkeeper conversions, M&A, carve-outs) Deloitte also lists a large workforce (about 470,000 employees globally), which can be helpful when you need specialized resources or multi-location coordination. Ernst & Young LLP (EY) EY highlights its role in building trust in capital markets and its global capabilities across assurance, tax, consulting, and advisory . EY also emphasizes forward-leaning focus areas such as Artificial Intelligence and Digital Transformation , which may appeal to sponsors who want an auditor comfortable with modern data environments and evolving control frameworks. EY’s brand messaging (“Building a better working world”) and global footprint can be especially relevant for organizations that prefer a standardized approach across regions, subsidiaries, or affiliated entities. Pricing and contracting considerations Neither provider includes public pricing in the provided data. In practice, audit fees for large firms are typically driven by plan size, participant counts, number of payroll feeds, investment complexity, ESOP/DB actuarial components, and timing constraints. When comparing Deloitte vs EY, ask both firms for a proposal that clearly outlines: Planned staffing model (partner/manager/senior mix) Timeline and PBC (prepared-by-client) expectations Experience with your plan type (e.g., ESOP or defined benefit) Approach to internal controls, SOC 1 reliance, and data requests How to choose between Deloitte and EY Choose Deloitte if you value a deep bench across cyber, technology, and business process services alongside your benefit plan audit—especially during system changes or complex operational events. Choose EY if you prioritize high 401(k) audit volume in the provided stats and want a firm that strongly emphasizes assurance quality and modern transformation themes. For many plan sponsors, the deciding factor is the engagement team you’ll work with day-to-day. Request references for plans similar to yours, confirm who will actually perform fieldwork, and compare how each firm will keep the audit efficient while meeting ERISA and DOL expectations.