Colonial Surety vs The Hartford

Compare Colonial Surety Company and The Hartford side by side.

CategoryColonial Surety CompanyThe Hartford
Year Founded1,9301,810
Employees54—
HeadquartersWoodcliff Lake, NJHartford, CT
Websitecolonialsurety.com/thehartford.com/
Accreditations——
LocationsWoodcliff Lake, NJ, Woodcliff Lake, NJHartford, CT

Comparison Details

Colonial Surety vs The Hartford: ERISA Fidelity Bond Comparison Both Colonial Surety Company and The Hartford provide ERISA Fidelity Bonds designed to help retirement plans comply with ERISA bonding requirements. If you sponsor or advise a 401(k) or 403(b) plan, the best choice often comes down to how you want to buy and manage the bond (fully digital vs. broader carrier relationship), the insurer’s scale and longevity, and whether you also want optional coverage like fiduciary liability insurance . At-a-glance differences Founded: Colonial Surety (1930) vs The Hartford (1810) Headquarters: Woodcliff Lake, NJ vs Hartford, CT Plans supported: Both support 401(k) and 403(b) Buying experience: Colonial Surety emphasizes instant online quote/purchase/print/e-file Carrier profile: The Hartford is a large, legacy national insurer; Colonial Surety is a smaller, specialized provider (54 employees listed) How each insurer approaches ERISA bonding Colonial Surety Company Colonial Surety positions its ERISA bond offering around speed and simplicity . Plan sponsors and retirement professionals can typically quote, purchase, print, or e-file an ERISA Fidelity Bond through a digital platform built for convenience on desktop or mobile. This can be a strong fit when you need to satisfy an audit request, finalize a plan setup, or quickly address a compliance gap. Colonial Surety is also noted as A.M. Best rated A (Excellent) , which can matter when evaluating insurer financial strength for a required bond. The Hartford The Hartford is one of the most established names in U.S. insurance, founded in 1810 . Its ERISA Fidelity Bonds are positioned as part of a broader business insurance relationship, which may appeal to employers that prefer consolidating coverage with a single national carrier. The Hartford’s ERISA bond description also highlights common compliance parameters: ERISA generally requires bonding for those who handle plan funds, often at 10% of assets handled , with typical limits ranging from $1,000 up to $500,000 (or $1 million for plans holding company stock). This framing can be helpful for administrators who want a carrier that clearly communicates ERISA-related coverage benchmarks. Coverage and add-on protections Both providers mention options beyond the ERISA bond itself—most notably fiduciary liability insurance . While an ERISA fidelity bond protects the plan against losses from fraud or dishonesty, fiduciary liability insurance generally addresses allegations of mismanagement or breach of fiduciary duty. If you want a more comprehensive risk management approach, compare how each carrier packages or supports these complementary coverages. Which is better for your plan? Choose Colonial Surety if your priority is a fast, self-serve online process to quote, buy, and produce bond documentation quickly—especially useful for time-sensitive compliance needs. Choose The Hartford if you value a large, long-established national insurer and may want ERISA bonding as part of a broader insurance relationship and guidance around common ERISA limit conventions. Next step: confirm your plan type (401(k) or 403(b)), estimate required bond amount based on assets handled, and compare how each insurer delivers proof of coverage and ongoing servicing for renewals or plan changes.