# Colonial Surety vs Jet Insurance
Source: https://planprovider.pro/compare/colonial-surety-vs-jet-insurance

> Compare Colonial Surety vs Jet Insurance for ERISA fidelity bonds—ratings, plan support, digital purchase experience, and who each insurer fits best.

Compare Colonial Surety Company and Jet Insurance Company side by side.

| Category|Colonial Surety Company|Jet Insurance Company|

| Year Founded|1,930|2,019|

| Employees|54|—|

| Headquarters|Woodcliff Lake, NJ|Charlotte, NC|

| Website|colonialsurety.com/|jetsurety.com/fidelity-bonds|

| Accreditations|—|—|

| Locations|Woodcliff Lake, NJ, Woodcliff Lake, NJ|Charlotte, NC, Dallas, TX, Sacramento, CA|

## Comparison Details

Colonial Surety vs Jet Insurance: ERISA Fidelity Bond Comparison Choosing an ERISA fidelity bond provider is a practical decision: you need compliant coverage (typically at least 10% of plan assets, subject to ERISA limits), quick issuance, and confidence the insurer can support your plan over time. Below is a side-by-side comparison of Colonial Surety Company and Jet Insurance Company —two insurers offering fidelity/surety solutions, including ERISA bonds for retirement plans. Company profile and longevity Colonial Surety Company (founded 1930) is a long-established insurer headquartered in Woodcliff Lake, NJ , with a small team (~ 54 employees ). Its long operating history may appeal to plan sponsors who prioritize a proven track record and a well-known ERISA bond specialist. Jet Insurance Company (founded 2019) is a newer entrant headquartered in Charlotte, NC , with additional offices noted in Dallas, TX and Sacramento, CA . Jet positions itself as a modern, direct-to-customer surety and fidelity bond carrier focused on speed and simplicity. Financial strength and ratings Colonial Surety notes an A “Excellent” rating from A.M. Best , which can be a key reassurance for fiduciaries evaluating insurer stability. Jet Insurance highlights A.M. Best credit rating upgrades and emphasizes balance sheet strength and operating performance. If you value momentum and a growth-oriented carrier, Jet’s recent upgrades may be a positive signal. Plans supported (who each insurer fits) Both providers support ERISA bonds for common employer-sponsored plans, but their stated coverage breadth differs: Colonial Surety : supports 401(k) and 403(b) plans—ideal if your needs are straightforward and centered on these plan types. Jet Insurance : supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit plans, and ESOPs —a broader list that may suit organizations with multiple plan types or more complex benefit structures. Buying experience and speed Colonial Surety emphasizes a highly digital ERISA bond workflow where you can instantly quote, purchase, print, or e-file online from desktop or mobile. This is particularly helpful when you’re up against an audit request, onboarding deadline, or Form 5500 season tasks. Jet Insurance markets itself as a direct decision-maker (reducing reliance on intermediaries) with a mission to modernize surety/fidelity bonding through high-speed service and a streamlined customer experience. Product focus and related coverage Colonial Surety is widely positioned around ERISA fidelity bonds and also points plan sponsors toward fiduciary liability insurance options for broader protection beyond theft/fraud coverage. Jet Insurance offers ERISA bonds alongside a wider menu of fidelity and surety products (e.g., employee dishonesty and financial institution bonds ), which may be useful if your organization wants to consolidate multiple bond needs with one carrier. How to choose between Colonial Surety and Jet Insurance Choose Colonial Surety if you value longstanding history , an A (Excellent) AM Best rating , and an instant online ERISA bond process built specifically for plan sponsors and retirement professionals. Choose Jet Insurance if you want a newer, modern direct-to-customer carrier , need support for additional plan types (like ESOP or defined benefit ), or prefer a provider focused on reducing delays from traditional middleman models. Next step: confirm your plan type(s), required bond amount, and whether you also need fiduciary liability coverage. Then compare quote speed, documentation delivery, and the insurer rating details that matter most to your fiduciary process.

[View all provider comparisons on PlanProvider.Pro](https://planprovider.pro/compare)

&copy; 2026 PlanProvider.Pro
