# CNA Surety vs Old Republic
Source: https://planprovider.pro/compare/cna-surety-vs-old-republic

> Compare CNA Surety vs Old Republic Surety for ERISA fidelity bonds—history, digital issuance tools, and fit for 401(k)/403(b) plans.

Compare CNA Surety and Old Republic Surety Company side by side.

| Category|CNA Surety|Old Republic Surety Company|

| Year Founded|1,897|1,923|

| Employees|—|—|

| Headquarters|Sioux Falls, SD|Brookfield, WI|

| Website|cnasurety.com/|orsurety.com/|

| Accreditations|—|—|

| Locations|Sioux Falls, SD|Brookfield, WI|

## Comparison Details

CNA Surety vs Old Republic Surety Company (ERISA Fidelity Bonds) Choosing an ERISA fidelity bond provider is a compliance decision as much as it is a risk-management one. Both CNA Surety and Old Republic Surety Company offer ERISA bonds designed to protect plan assets from fraud or dishonesty and help plan sponsors meet federal bonding requirements for common retirement plans like 401(k) and 403(b) plans. Where they differ is in their positioning: CNA emphasizes long-standing surety expertise and broad footprint, while Old Republic emphasizes speed and simplicity through a dedicated online issuance platform. At-a-glance comparison Founded: CNA Surety (1897) vs Old Republic Surety Company (1923) Headquarters: Sioux Falls, SD vs Brookfield, WI Plans supported: Both support 401(k) and 403(b) Primary focus: Both are insurers specializing in surety and ERISA fidelity bonds Core ERISA bond requirements: what both insurers help you satisfy ERISA generally requires that individuals who “handle” plan funds be bonded. Coverage is commonly calculated with the federal baseline of at least 10% of plan funds handled (subject to ERISA rules and limitations). Both CNA Surety and Old Republic Surety Company provide bonds intended to satisfy these requirements so plan sponsors can maintain compliance and reduce exposure to losses from employee dishonesty. CNA Surety strengths CNA Surety (also known as Western Surety ) traces its roots to 1897 , giving it one of the longer operating histories among surety providers. For plan sponsors, that longevity can be a proxy for stability, established underwriting practices, and experience serving a wide variety of organizations. Deep surety heritage: Over a century in the surety market can matter if you value a provider with long-standing underwriting and claims infrastructure. Broad footprint: The company notes a global presence with offices across the U.S., Europe, and Canada—useful for organizations that prefer a provider with wider geographic reach. ERISA bond specialization: Positioned as a leading provider of ERISA fidelity bonds for retirement and health plans, which can be reassuring if you want a specialist rather than a generalist. Old Republic Surety Company strengths Old Republic Surety Company , founded in 1923 , differentiates itself with a strong emphasis on operational efficiency for plan administrators. Its ERISA bond experience is paired with a technology-forward workflow designed to reduce friction when you need coverage quickly. Fast online issuance: Old Republic highlights its BONDSTAR™ platform, which lets users instantly issue and print ERISA bonds in minutes—helpful for time-sensitive compliance needs. Streamlined administration: A purpose-built platform can reduce back-and-forth, especially for teams managing multiple plans or renewals. Fit for different plan sizes: The company positions its ERISA bonding as suitable for both small and large retirement funds, which may appeal to growing employers. Which is better for your plan? Pick CNA Surety if you prioritize a long-established surety provider with a broad footprint and a legacy-focused approach to ERISA bonding. Choose Old Republic Surety Company if your top priority is a digital, rapid issuance process —especially if you want to generate a compliant bond quickly through an online platform. Next steps: confirm your required bond amount based on plan assets handled, verify the bond names the correct plan and insured parties, and ensure the bond form meets your auditor or recordkeeper’s documentation expectations.

[View all provider comparisons on PlanProvider.Pro](https://planprovider.pro/compare)

&copy; 2026 PlanProvider.Pro
