CliftonLarsonAllen vs BDO

Compare Cliftonlarsonallen LLP and BDO USA P.C. side by side.

CategoryCliftonlarsonallen LLPBDO USA P.C.
Year Founded2,0121,910
Employees8,800—
HeadquartersAkron, OHPhiladelphia, PA
Websiteclaconnect.com/en/services/employee-benefit-plansbdo.com/locations/bdo-philadelphia-office
Latest Audit Statistics3,291 plans audited1,274 plans audited · $454.9B AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare
AccreditationsAICPA Member, Other, AICPA EBPAQCAICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC
Published Pricing——
LocationsSwansea, IL, Albuquerque, NM, Albuquerque, NM, Saint Louis, MO, Akron, OHPhiladelphia, PA

Comparison Details

CLA vs BDO: Which auditor is the better fit for your benefit plan? Choosing an employee benefit plan auditor is about more than brand recognition—it’s about proven plan-audit experience, the types of plans supported, geographic coverage, and the depth of ERISA-specific resources. Below is a practical comparison of CliftonLarsonAllen LLP (CLA) and BDO USA, P.C. for organizations evaluating a 401(k) audit or other retirement and benefit plan audit needs. Quick snapshot Founded: CLA (2012, via merger) vs BDO (1910) Scale: CLA reports ~8,800 employees; BDO employee count not provided here 401(k) audits (2024): CLA 3,291 vs BDO 1,274 Plan types supported: CLA: 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP BDO: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, health & welfare Audit volume and specialization If you want an auditor with extensive repetition in 401(k) plan audits, the 2024 audit counts show a meaningful difference. CLA audited 3,291 401(k) plans in 2024 versus BDO’s 1,274 . Higher audit volume can correlate with more standardized testing approaches, deeper benchmarking across plan designs, and familiarity with common operational pitfalls (eligibility, deferrals, match calculations, loans, distributions, and payroll-to-recordkeeper reconciliations). CLA also notes it performs the most benefit plan audits in the country based on Department of Labor rankings and highlights membership in the AICPA Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center —signals for firms that prioritize benefit-plan audit quality frameworks. Plan coverage: retirement-only vs broader benefits Both firms cover core retirement plan audits— 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, and ESOP . A key differentiator is that BDO lists health & welfare plan support, which can matter if your organization prefers one firm across retirement and welfare benefit plan audits. On the other hand, CLA explicitly lists 457 plan support, which may be important for governmental or tax-exempt employers offering deferred compensation arrangements. Footprint, resources, and how teams are deployed CLA emphasizes a large national footprint with 130+ offices and a “local presence backed by national expertise,” plus participation in the CLA Global network for organizations with cross-border considerations. CLA’s headquarters is listed as Akron, OH in the provided data. BDO is also a major national firm and highlights office-based access (for example, its Philadelphia office at 1801 Market Street). If proximity to a specific metro office and industry advisory bench is a priority, BDO’s location-driven model may be appealing for organizations wanting in-person cadence. Related services that can affect the audit experience Beyond the audit itself, CLA advertises benefit-plan-adjacent capabilities such as Form 5500 preparation , ERISA and non-ERISA audits , ACA reporting , and ESOP consulting . If you want a single provider to coordinate audit work with compliance filings and plan governance support, CLA may offer a more explicitly packaged benefit plan services suite. BDO positions itself broadly across assurance, tax, and advisory services and is well known for serving complex, multi-entity businesses across industries—useful if your benefit plan audit is tied closely to broader financial statement audit coordination. How to choose between CLA and BDO Choose CLA if you prioritize very high 401(k) audit volume, explicitly stated benefit plan audit quality affiliations, and packaged services like Form 5500/ACA support. Choose BDO if you want a firm that explicitly supports health & welfare plan audits and you prefer a large, established assurance brand with strong office presence in key metros. Tip: Ask both firms for a benefit plan audit engagement timeline, staffing model (partner/manager continuity), experience with your plan’s recordkeeper/TPA, and how they handle common audit pressure points like SOC report reliance, payroll testing, and late contribution corrections.