Betterment vs Vanguard

Compare Betterment at Work and The Vanguard Group, Inc. side by side.

CategoryBetterment at WorkThe Vanguard Group, Inc.
Year Founded2,0091,975
Employees46620,000
HeadquartersNew York, NYMalvern, PA
Websitebetterment.com/workworkplace.vanguard.com/home
Latest Client Statistics2,000 clients · $30M AUM1,400 clients · $523.0B AUM
ServicesFiduciary Audit Services, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(38) Investment Manager, RecordkeepingPlan Design Consulting, Compliance Services, Recordkeeping
Plans Supported401(k), Solo 401(k)SEP IRA, 401(k)
Accreditations——
Published PricingEssential: $100 base fee, $5/employee
Pro: $150 base fee, $7/employee
—
LocationsNew York, NYMalvern, PA

Comparison Details

Betterment at Work vs Vanguard: which 401(k) administrator fits your plan? Betterment at Work and The Vanguard Group are both well-known names in retirement, but they approach 401(k) administration from very different angles. Betterment brings a fintech-first, integration-heavy experience with published monthly fees, while Vanguard is a long-established, large-scale retirement provider known for its low-cost investment lineup and institutional capabilities. Below is a practical comparison for plan sponsors evaluating /compare/betterment-vs-vanguard . Company profile and scale Betterment at Work (founded 2009, ~466 employees, HQ: New York, NY) is an SEC-registered investment advisor offering retirement plans alongside broader financial wellness tools. Vanguard (founded 1975, ~20,000 employees) is one of the largest retirement and investment providers in the U.S., widely recognized for its index-fund heritage and client-owned structure. Scale can matter if you want a provider built for very large participant populations and institutional processes (Vanguard) versus a modern, fast-to-implement platform optimized for streamlined sponsor workflows (Betterment). Plans supported Betterment at Work: 401(k) and Solo 401(k) support. Vanguard: 401(k) and SEP IRA support. If you’re comparing options for a self-employed owner, Betterment’s Solo 401(k) support may be a differentiator. If you’re considering a simpler employer plan like a SEP IRA , Vanguard is the one listed here supporting that plan type. Core services: recordkeeping, compliance, and plan design Both providers cover the essentials plan sponsors expect from an administrator— recordkeeping , compliance , and plan design . Differences show up in fiduciary and operational features: Betterment at Work lists added capabilities such as 3(38) investment management and fiduciary audit support , plus compliance expertise including daily monitoring and annual testing. Vanguard emphasizes sponsor support, technology, and participant outcomes, typically paired with broad access to low-cost Vanguard funds and ETFs . If you want to outsource more investment fiduciary responsibility, Betterment’s explicit 3(38) offering can be appealing. If your priority is a deep, low-cost investment bench and a long institutional track record, Vanguard is often shortlisted. Pricing transparency Betterment publishes plan-level pricing, which helps sponsors estimate costs quickly: Betterment Essential: $100/month base + $5/employee/month Betterment Pro: $150/month base + $7/employee/month Vanguard pricing is not provided in the data above, and many large providers price based on plan size, service scope, and investment lineup. If you want instant, predictable budgeting, Betterment’s posted fees are a clear advantage; if you expect institutional or custom pricing, Vanguard may be evaluated through a proposal process. Integrations and day-to-day administration Betterment highlights seamless payroll integrations with 350+ providers , which can reduce manual file work and ongoing administrative friction. Vanguard also invests in technology, but payroll integration breadth is not specified here. For sponsors prioritizing implementation speed and automation, Betterment’s integration footprint is a key differentiator. Client footprint (as reported) Betterment at Work (401k, 2025): ~2,000 clients; ~ $30M AUM reported in the dataset. Vanguard (401k, 2024): ~1,400 clients; ~ $2.55T AUM; ~ 4.8M participants. These figures suggest very different market positioning: Betterment with a growing, modern platform model, and Vanguard with massive asset scale and participant reach. Which administrator is better for your business? Choose Betterment at Work if you want published pricing, strong payroll integrations, and the option to delegate investment management via 3(38) . Choose Vanguard if you want a long-standing provider with enormous retirement plan scale and a reputation built around low-cost funds/ETFs and institutional plan support. The best fit ultimately depends on your plan size, desired fiduciary outsourcing, integration needs, and whether transparent flat pricing or proposal-based institutional pricing is more important to you.