Betterment vs Principal Financial Group

Compare Betterment at Work and Principal Financial Group, Inc. side by side.

CategoryBetterment at WorkPrincipal Financial Group, Inc.
Year Founded2,0091,879
Employees46620,000
HeadquartersNew York, NYDes Moines, IA
Websitebetterment.com/workprincipal.com/individuals/invest-retire/retirement-plans/401k-403b-retirement-plans
Latest Client Statistics2,000 clients · $30M AUM11,086 clients · $540.4B AUM
ServicesFiduciary Audit Services, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(38) Investment Manager, RecordkeepingCompliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, Recordkeeping, Participant Investment Advice
Plans Supported401(k), Solo 401(k)401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP
Accreditations——
Published PricingEssential: $100 base fee, $5/employee
Pro: $150 base fee, $7/employee
—
LocationsNew York, NYDes Moines, IA

Comparison Details

Betterment at Work vs Principal Financial Group: which retirement plan administrator fits your organization? Betterment at Work and Principal Financial Group, Inc. are both well-known retirement plan providers, but they’re built for different buyer profiles. Betterment at Work is a modern fintech administrator (founded 2009; ~466 employees) focused on streamlined 401(k) administration, digital participant experience, and clear, published pricing. Principal (founded 1879; ~20,000 employees) is a large, diversified financial services company with broad retirement plan capabilities across multiple plan types and a deep bench of resources for complex organizations. Plan types and flexibility Betterment at Work: Supports 401(k) and solo 401(k) . This narrower lineup can be a benefit if you want a focused, standardized 401(k) experience with fewer moving parts. Principal: Supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, and ESOP plans. If you’re a nonprofit, public employer, or a company with legacy/complex plan needs, Principal’s breadth is a key differentiator. Services and fiduciary support Both providers cover core administration needs like recordkeeping , compliance , and plan design . The difference is in how they package fiduciary and participant support. Betterment at Work services: Includes compliance and recordkeeping plus 3(38) investment management and support aligned with fiduciary oversight (listed as fiduciary audit support). This can appeal to employers looking to outsource investment discretion and reduce internal workload. Principal services: Includes participant advice in addition to recordkeeping/compliance. Principal often fits employers that want a large provider with established advice and education infrastructure for participants. Pricing transparency and cost predictability One of the clearest differences is pricing visibility. Betterment at Work pricing (published): Essential: $100/month base + $5 per employee/month Pro: $150/month base + $7 per employee/month This structure makes budgeting straightforward, especially for small and mid-sized teams comparing providers on an “all-in admin” basis. Principal pricing: Not listed in the provided data. In practice, large providers commonly price based on plan size, service mix, and investment lineup—so you’ll typically request a proposal to compare total plan costs. Technology, payroll integrations, and day-to-day administration Betterment at Work: Emphasizes a modern, automated platform with daily monitoring , annual testing , and payroll integrations with 350+ providers . This is a strong fit if your priority is operational simplicity and clean data flow between payroll and the plan. Principal: As a long-standing institution, Principal is often chosen for scale, established processes, and the ability to support diverse plan designs across industries. If you’re consolidating multiple benefit lines (retirement plus insurance/benefits), Principal may provide a more unified vendor relationship. Scale and market presence Betterment at Work: Reported ~2,000 401(k) clients (2025 data provided) and a fintech-first model headquartered in New York, NY . Principal: A significantly larger organization headquartered in Des Moines, IA , with notable plan counts across multiple types (e.g., 403(b) , 457 , and defined benefit client volumes in the provided 2025 stats). How to choose between Betterment and Principal Choose Betterment at Work if you want transparent monthly pricing , strong payroll integrations , and a modern 401(k) experience with optional 3(38) investment management. Choose Principal if you need multiple plan types (like 403(b), 457, defined benefit, or ESOP), want a large provider’s infrastructure, or prefer a broader financial services relationship beyond retirement. For a final decision, ask each provider for a proposal that itemizes administrative fees, participant fees, investment expense assumptions, fiduciary services (3(16)/3(38) where applicable), and implementation timelines—then compare on total cost and operational fit.