Betterment vs John Hancock

Compare Betterment at Work and John Hancock side by side.

CategoryBetterment at WorkJohn Hancock
Year Founded2,0091,863
Employees4664,000
HeadquartersNew York, NYBoston, MA
Websitebetterment.com/workjohnhancock.com/plan-sponsors.html
Latest Client Statistics2,000 clients · $30M AUM54,358 clients · $253.0B AUM
ServicesFiduciary Audit Services, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(38) Investment Manager, RecordkeepingRecordkeeping, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting
Plans Supported401(k), Solo 401(k)401(k), 403(b), 457, Defined Benefit, ESOP
Accreditations——
Published PricingEssential: $100 base fee, $5/employee
Pro: $150 base fee, $7/employee
—
LocationsNew York, NYBoston, MA, Westwood, MA, Valhalla, NY, Boston, MA, Boston, MA

Comparison Details

Betterment at Work vs. John Hancock: which retirement plan administrator fits your plan? Betterment at Work and John Hancock both support retirement plan administration, but they’re built for different sponsor needs. Betterment at Work (founded 2009, ~466 employees, HQ New York) is a fintech-first, SEC-registered investment advisor offering a modern 401(k) experience with strong automation and payroll connectivity. John Hancock (founded 1863, ~4,000 employees, HQ Boston) is a long-established financial services institution offering a broad retirement platform that can support everything from defined contribution to defined benefit arrangements. Plan types and flexibility Betterment at Work: Supports 401(k) and solo 401(k) . This narrower focus can be an advantage for employers that want a streamlined, tech-forward 401(k) without added complexity. John Hancock: Supports 401(k), 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP , and more. If you anticipate plan diversification (nonprofit/government plans, pension components, or specialized designs), John Hancock’s breadth is a key differentiator. Services and fiduciary support Both providers cover the core administrative pillars— plan design, compliance, and recordkeeping . Betterment at Work also lists additional fiduciary-related capabilities, including 3(38) investment management and fiduciary audit support, plus ongoing compliance operations like daily monitoring and annual testing. John Hancock emphasizes a consultative service model and established retirement plan servicing, typically delivered in partnership with advisors and consultants. Choose Betterment if you want a provider that can take on more investment-fiduciary responsibility via 3(38) and keep administration highly automated. Choose John Hancock if you prefer a traditional, relationship-driven platform with extensive plan menu options and broad sponsor use cases. Payroll integrations and day-to-day administration Betterment at Work highlights seamless payroll integrations with 350+ providers , which can reduce manual file work and help keep contributions and data flowing smoothly. This can be especially valuable for small-to-midsize employers that want fewer administrative touchpoints. John Hancock also offers streamlined administration and reporting tools, but its value proposition is often strongest when paired with an advisor-led service approach and larger platform capabilities. Pricing transparency One of the clearest differences is pricing visibility. Betterment at Work pricing (published): Essential: $100/month base + $5/employee/month Pro: $150/month base + $7/employee/month John Hancock pricing: Not listed here; many plans are quoted based on plan size, investment lineup, service model, and advisor arrangement. If you want predictable, easy-to-compare fees, Betterment’s tiered structure can simplify budgeting. If you need a tailored package (or have a complex plan design), John Hancock’s custom quoting may better match your requirements. Scale, track record, and “best fit” John Hancock’s long operating history and large employee base reflect institutional scale. Betterment’s more recent founding and fintech orientation typically appeal to employers prioritizing a modern participant experience and automation. Client data also suggests Betterment has meaningful 401(k) adoption (e.g., ~2,000 401(k) clients in 2025 per provided stats), while John Hancock’s provided stats show activity across additional plan types (e.g., 457 and defined benefit). Bottom line Pick Betterment at Work for a modern 401(k) administrator with transparent monthly pricing, strong payroll integrations, and optional 3(38) fiduciary investment management. Pick John Hancock if you need a provider with broad plan-type coverage (including 403(b), 457, defined benefit, ESOP ) and a more traditional, consultative retirement platform backed by a long-standing financial institution.