Betterment vs Fidelity Investments

Compare Betterment at Work and Fidelity Investments side by side.

CategoryBetterment at WorkFidelity Investments
Year Founded2,0091,949
Employees46650,000
HeadquartersNew York, NYBoston, MA
Websitebetterment.com/workfidelityworkplace.com/
Latest Client Statistics2,000 clients · $30M AUM37,255 clients · $4.4T AUM
ServicesFiduciary Audit Services, Compliance Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(38) Investment Manager, RecordkeepingRecordkeeping
Plans Supported401(k), Solo 401(k)401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit
Accreditations——
Published PricingEssential: $100 base fee, $5/employee
Pro: $150 base fee, $7/employee
Fidelity Advantage 401(k): $100 base fee, $8.33/employee, $500 setup fee
LocationsNew York, NYBoston, MA

Comparison Details

Betterment at Work vs Fidelity Investments (Workplace): Which 401(k) Administrator Fits Your Plan? Betterment at Work and Fidelity Workplace are both well-known names in retirement plans, but they’re built for different employer needs. Betterment at Work is a fintech-first 401(k) platform designed to simplify administration with automation and broad payroll connectivity. Fidelity is a large, established financial services provider with deep experience across multiple plan types and large participant populations. Company scale and market focus Betterment at Work (founded 2009, ~466 employees; HQ: New York, NY) positions itself as a modern, tech-forward provider offering automated investing and financial wellness tools alongside retirement plan administration. Fidelity Investments (~50,000 employees; HQ: Boston, MA) is a multinational financial services firm with significant scale in the workplace retirement market, supporting very large participant bases across plan segments. If you value a streamlined, software-led experience and a “modern benefits” approach, Betterment often aligns well. If you want a provider with broad institutional footprint and long-standing workplace infrastructure, Fidelity may be the better match. Plans supported: flexibility vs breadth Betterment at Work : supports 401(k) and Solo 401(k) plans—commonly appealing to small and midsize employers and owner-only scenarios. Fidelity Workplace : supports 401(k) , 403(b) , and defined benefit plans—better suited for organizations needing multiple plan types, including nonprofit/education (403(b)) or pension-style benefits. Services and fiduciary support Service scope is a key differentiator for sponsors comparing administrators. Betterment at Work services : recordkeeping plus compliance , plan design , and fiduciary support including 3(38) investment management. Betterment also highlights ongoing compliance monitoring and annual testing as part of its administration model. Fidelity Workplace services : listed as recordkeeping in the provided data. Fidelity’s broader ecosystem can be attractive for sponsors who prefer a large provider’s workplace platform, but sponsors should confirm which compliance and fiduciary services are included versus optional add-ons. Payroll integrations and admin experience Betterment at Work emphasizes seamless setup and ongoing administration through technology, including payroll integrations with 350+ providers . For employers prioritizing fewer manual steps, faster onboarding, and automated data flow, this can materially reduce administrative burden. Fidelity’s workplace platform is built for scale and is commonly used by larger organizations; however, integration depth and implementation experience can vary by payroll and plan complexity—something to validate during demos. Pricing comparison (base, per-employee, setup) Based on the pricing provided, both can start with similar base fees, but the per-employee and setup costs differ. Betterment at Work : Essential: $100/mo + $5/employee/mo Pro: $150/mo + $7/employee/mo Fidelity Advantage 401(k) : $100/mo + $8.33/employee/mo + $500 setup fee For cost-sensitive small employers, Betterment’s lower per-employee pricing (and no listed setup fee) may be compelling. Fidelity’s setup fee and higher per-employee charge may be easier to justify for sponsors who value Fidelity’s scale, plan breadth, or existing relationships. Client footprint and participation Betterment at Work : reported ~2,000 401(k) clients (2025) in the provided dataset. Fidelity : reported large participant counts across plan types (e.g., millions in 403(b) and defined benefit participation in the provided dataset), reflecting significant enterprise and institutional reach. Which provider is best for you? Choose Betterment at Work if you want a modern, automated 401(k) experience with strong payroll integrations, bundled compliance support, and optional 3(38) fiduciary investment management. Choose Fidelity Workplace if you need broader plan type support (like 403(b) or defined benefit), want a large-scale workplace provider, or prefer a well-established institutional platform. Next step: request a proposal from each that confirms total all-in costs (including any fund/asset-based fees), fiduciary roles (3(16)/3(38)), payroll integration specifics, and what compliance testing/support is included for your plan size and complexity.