# BDO vs Ernst &amp; Young
Source: https://planprovider.pro/compare/bdo-vs-ernst-young

> Compare BDO USA P.C. vs Ernst &amp; Young (EY) for employee benefit plan audits—scale, focus, and 2024 401(k) audit volume and AUM.

Compare BDO USA P.C. and Ernst & Young LLP side by side.

| Category|BDO USA P.C.|Ernst & Young LLP|

| Year Founded|1,910|1,989|

| Employees|—|—|

| Headquarters|Philadelphia, PA|New York, NY|

| Website|bdo.com/locations/bdo-philadelphia-office|ey.com/|

| Latest Audit Statistics|1,274 plans audited · $454.9B AUM|638 plans audited · $1.0T AUM|

| Plans Supported|401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare|401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare|

| Accreditations|AICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC|AICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member|

| Published Pricing|—|—|

| Locations|Philadelphia, PA|New York, NY|

## Comparison Details

BDO vs Ernst &amp; Young (EY): comparing employee benefit plan auditors Choosing an auditor for an employee benefit plan (EBP) is about more than brand recognition—it’s about experience with your plan type, depth of resources, responsiveness, and a track record auditing plans like yours. Below is a practical comparison of BDO USA P.C. and Ernst &amp; Young LLP (EY) , two major assurance firms that both support common retirement and welfare plan audits, including 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit , ESOP , and health &amp; welfare plans. At-a-glance comparison Provider type: Independent audit firms (assurance, tax, advisory) Plan types supported (both): 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, health &amp; welfare Founded: BDO (1910) vs EY (1989) 2024 401(k) plans audited (DB data): BDO 1,274 vs EY 638 2024 401(k) AUM audited (DB data): BDO $454.9B vs EY $1.006T Scale and audit mix: volume vs mega-plan exposure Based on the 2024 401(k) audit statistics provided, BDO audited more 401(k) plans (1,274) than EY (638). Higher plan counts can indicate a broad EBP audit practice with repeatable processes across many plan sponsors and third-party administrators. Meanwhile, EY’s audited 401(k) AUM is significantly larger ($1.006T vs BDO’s $454.9B). That gap suggests EY may be more concentrated in very large, complex plans (or sponsors with sizable participant populations and investment lineups), where audit coordination, internal controls, and stakeholder management can be more demanding. Firm positioning and what it may mean for plan sponsors BDO USA P.C. BDO is a long-established firm (founded in 1910) with a strong U.S. presence and regional offices such as its Philadelphia location at 1801 Market Street . For plan sponsors, BDO can be a fit when you want a large national firm but still value local-market access and a potentially more mid-market oriented service model. May align well with sponsors seeking a balance of national capabilities and regional delivery teams Notable breadth in industries mentioned (e.g., healthcare, manufacturing, real estate, technology) Higher 401(k) plan audit count in 2024 may indicate strong repeatable EBP audit operations Ernst &amp; Young LLP (EY) EY is one of the world’s largest professional services networks and emphasizes trust in capital markets, innovation, and transformation (including AI and digital transformation themes). With a major presence including New York (395 9th Ave) and global reach, EY can be compelling for plan sponsors with complex governance, multinational operations, or highly scrutinized reporting environments. Often associated with large enterprise clients and complex, high-AUM plans Global network can help when benefits administration touches multiple jurisdictions Large 2024 audited AUM suggests substantial exposure to “mega-plan” audit complexity Pricing transparency and how to evaluate cost Neither provider lists public pricing in the data provided. In practice, EBP audit fees typically vary based on participant count, plan assets, number of funds, ESOP complexity, benefit payments, internal control environment, and the quality/timeliness of records from your TPA and custodian. Ask both firms for a fixed-fee proposal (or clear not-to-exceed language) Request a detailed PBC (Provided By Client) list and timeline assumptions Confirm who will staff the engagement (partner/manager continuity matters) How to choose between BDO and EY Choose BDO if you want a large, established auditor with strong 401(k) audit volume and a delivery model that may suit a wide range of plan sizes, including mid-to-large sponsors looking for consistency and local office access. Choose EY if your plan is extremely large or highly complex, you need global scale, or you expect deep resources for sophisticated stakeholders—supported by EY’s very high audited 401(k) AUM in 2024. Next step: request proposals from both and compare (1) EBP-specific experience with your plan type (401(k), 403(b), DB, ESOP, H&amp;W), (2) the proposed engagement team, and (3) the timeline and audit approach for your Form 5500 filing needs.

[View all provider comparisons on PlanProvider.Pro](https://planprovider.pro/compare)

&copy; 2026 PlanProvider.Pro
