# Baker Tilly vs RSM
Source: https://planprovider.pro/compare/baker-tilly-vs-rsm

> Compare Baker Tilly vs RSM for 401(k) plan audits—scale, focus, plan types supported, and 2024 audit volume to help you choose.

Compare Baker Tilly US LLP and RSM LLP side by side.

| Category|Baker Tilly US LLP|RSM LLP|

| Year Founded|1,931|1,926|

| Employees|10,001|—|

| Headquarters|Madison, WI|Chicago, IL|

| Website|bakertilly.com/|rsmus.com/|

| Latest Audit Statistics|3,801 plans audited · $917.5B AUM|989 plans audited · $111.6B AUM|

| Plans Supported|401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare|401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare|

| Accreditations|AICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC|—|

| Published Pricing|—|—|

| Locations|Madison, WI|Chicago, IL, Phoenix, AZ|

## Comparison Details

Baker Tilly vs RSM: comparing retirement plan auditors Choosing an auditor for a retirement plan isn’t just about signing an engagement letter—it’s about finding a firm with the right depth in employee benefit plan (EBP) audits, the capacity to handle your timeline, and the experience that matches your plan design. Below is a practical comparison of Baker Tilly US LLP and RSM US LLP for organizations evaluating a 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, or health &amp; welfare plan audit. Firm profile and footprint Baker Tilly US LLP (founded 1931) is a top-ten advisory, tax, and assurance firm with a large national presence and global reach through Baker Tilly International. HQ: Madison, WI . Reported workforce: 10,001 employees . RSM US LLP (founded 1926) is a leading assurance, tax, and consulting firm known for serving middle-market businesses across the U.S. HQ: Chicago, IL . What this can mean for you: Baker Tilly’s size and “coast-to-coast” positioning may appeal to multi-location sponsors or organizations wanting broad bench strength. RSM’s middle-market orientation may be a strong fit for growing employers that want a firm accustomed to scaling processes and controls as companies expand. Plan types supported Both firms support a wide range of benefit plan audits, including: 401(k) plans 403(b) plans Defined benefit plans ESOPs Health &amp; welfare plans If your organization sponsors multiple plans (for example, a 401(k) plus health &amp; welfare), either provider can potentially consolidate workstreams and coordinate deliverables across plan types. 401(k) audit scale (2024): volume and assets audited One of the clearest differentiators is recent 401(k) audit activity. Based on 2024 audit statistics: Baker Tilly : 3,801 401(k) plans audited; approximately $917.5B in associated assets audited. RSM : 989 401(k) plans audited; approximately $111.6B in associated assets audited. How to interpret this: Higher audit volume can indicate deeper specialization, more standardized EBP audit workflows, and greater staffing capacity during peak season. Lower volume doesn’t automatically mean “worse,” but it can be a prompt to ask detailed questions about team availability, reviewer experience, and how the firm handles busy-season bottlenecks. Headquarters vs local office needs Although the firms have different headquarters (Baker Tilly in Madison, WI; RSM in Chicago, IL), both reference a presence in Madison, WI in the provided information. If you prefer in-person fieldwork, local relationship management, or on-site walkthroughs, confirm which office will lead the engagement and where your day-to-day audit team will be based. Pricing and engagement approach: what to ask Pricing isn’t listed for either provider, so the best comparison comes from how each scopes and manages EBP audits. When requesting proposals, ask both firms to address: Expected timeline (planning, fieldwork, draft delivery, final issuance) and peak-season staffing plan Experience with your plan complexity (late deposits, eligibility issues, payroll integrations, ESOP valuations, DB actuarial coordination) PBC (prepared-by-client) list clarity and the tools/portals used for document exchange How they coordinate with your TPA, recordkeeper, and ERISA counsel Which auditor is the better fit? Choose Baker Tilly if you value a very large EBP audit footprint, broad national resources, and high 401(k) audit volume. Choose RSM if you want a firm widely recognized for serving middle-market organizations and you’re looking for a strong balance of assurance and business consulting support as your company grows. Ultimately, the best choice is the firm that can demonstrate relevant EBP expertise, a stable audit team, and a clear plan to deliver on time—especially if your Form 5500 filing deadlines are tight.

[View all provider comparisons on PlanProvider.Pro](https://planprovider.pro/compare)

&copy; 2026 PlanProvider.Pro
