| Category | Baker Tilly US LLP | RSM LLP |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,931 | 1,926 |
| Employees | 10,001 | — |
| Headquarters | Madison, WI | Chicago, IL |
| Website | bakertilly.com/ | rsmus.com/ |
| Latest Audit Statistics | 3,801 plans audited · $917.5B AUM | 989 plans audited · $111.6B AUM |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare | 401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare |
| Accreditations | AICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC | — |
| Published Pricing | — | — |
| Locations | Madison, WI | Chicago, IL, Phoenix, AZ |
Comparison Details
Baker Tilly vs RSM: comparing retirement plan auditors Choosing an auditor for a retirement plan isn’t just about signing an engagement letter—it’s about finding a firm with the right depth in employee benefit plan (EBP) audits, the capacity to handle your timeline, and the experience that matches your plan design. Below is a practical comparison of Baker Tilly US LLP and RSM US LLP for organizations evaluating a 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, or health & welfare plan audit. Firm profile and footprint Baker Tilly US LLP (founded 1931) is a top-ten advisory, tax, and assurance firm with a large national presence and global reach through Baker Tilly International. HQ: Madison, WI . Reported workforce: 10,001 employees . RSM US LLP (founded 1926) is a leading assurance, tax, and consulting firm known for serving middle-market businesses across the U.S. HQ: Chicago, IL . What this can mean for you: Baker Tilly’s size and “coast-to-coast” positioning may appeal to multi-location sponsors or organizations wanting broad bench strength. RSM’s middle-market orientation may be a strong fit for growing employers that want a firm accustomed to scaling processes and controls as companies expand. Plan types supported Both firms support a wide range of benefit plan audits, including: 401(k) plans 403(b) plans Defined benefit plans ESOPs Health & welfare plans If your organization sponsors multiple plans (for example, a 401(k) plus health & welfare), either provider can potentially consolidate workstreams and coordinate deliverables across plan types. 401(k) audit scale (2024): volume and assets audited One of the clearest differentiators is recent 401(k) audit activity. Based on 2024 audit statistics: Baker Tilly : 3,801 401(k) plans audited; approximately $917.5B in associated assets audited. RSM : 989 401(k) plans audited; approximately $111.6B in associated assets audited. How to interpret this: Higher audit volume can indicate deeper specialization, more standardized EBP audit workflows, and greater staffing capacity during peak season. Lower volume doesn’t automatically mean “worse,” but it can be a prompt to ask detailed questions about team availability, reviewer experience, and how the firm handles busy-season bottlenecks. Headquarters vs local office needs Although the firms have different headquarters (Baker Tilly in Madison, WI; RSM in Chicago, IL), both reference a presence in Madison, WI in the provided information. If you prefer in-person fieldwork, local relationship management, or on-site walkthroughs, confirm which office will lead the engagement and where your day-to-day audit team will be based. Pricing and engagement approach: what to ask Pricing isn’t listed for either provider, so the best comparison comes from how each scopes and manages EBP audits. When requesting proposals, ask both firms to address: Expected timeline (planning, fieldwork, draft delivery, final issuance) and peak-season staffing plan Experience with your plan complexity (late deposits, eligibility issues, payroll integrations, ESOP valuations, DB actuarial coordination) PBC (prepared-by-client) list clarity and the tools/portals used for document exchange How they coordinate with your TPA, recordkeeper, and ERISA counsel Which auditor is the better fit? Choose Baker Tilly if you value a very large EBP audit footprint, broad national resources, and high 401(k) audit volume. Choose RSM if you want a firm widely recognized for serving middle-market organizations and you’re looking for a strong balance of assurance and business consulting support as your company grows. Ultimately, the best choice is the firm that can demonstrate relevant EBP expertise, a stable audit team, and a clear plan to deliver on time—especially if your Form 5500 filing deadlines are tight.