Baker Tilly vs Plante Moran

Compare Baker Tilly US LLP and PLANTE & MORAN, PLLC side by side.

CategoryBaker Tilly US LLPPLANTE & MORAN, PLLC
Year Founded1,9311,924
Employees10,001—
HeadquartersMadison, WI—
Websitebakertilly.com/plantemoran.com/
Latest Audit Statistics3,801 plans audited · $917.5B AUM1,216 plans audited · $158.8B AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP
AccreditationsAICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQCAICPA EBPAQC, AICPA Member
Published Pricing——
LocationsMadison, WI—

Comparison Details

Baker Tilly vs Plante Moran: choosing an ERISA plan auditor Both Baker Tilly US LLP and PLANTE & MORAN, PLLC are large U.S. accounting firms that perform employee benefit plan (EBP) audits for retirement plans. If you’re selecting an auditor for a 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit plan, or ESOP , the best fit usually comes down to scale, plan specialization, geographic reach, and how much retirement-plan audit volume the firm handles each year. At-a-glance comparison Founded: Baker Tilly (1931) vs Plante Moran (1924) Headquarters: Baker Tilly (Madison, WI) vs Plante Moran (not listed) Employees: Baker Tilly (10,001) vs Plante Moran (not listed) Plans supported: Baker Tilly: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, health & welfare Plante Moran: 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP Audit scale and 401(k) volume One of the clearest differentiators is 401(k) plan audit volume . Higher volume can indicate deeper bench strength, established methodologies, and familiarity with common plan features (payroll integration, eligibility, match calculations, participant loans, distributions, SOC reports, and custodial platforms). Baker Tilly (2024): audited 3,801 401(k) plans with reported AUM of $917.5B . Plante Moran (2025): audited 1,216 401(k) plans with reported AUM of $158.8B . (Also shows 2024 activity of 3 plans in the provided dataset.) If you want an auditor with very large national plan-audit throughput, Baker Tilly’s reported 401(k) volume is substantially higher in the available data. If you prefer a large firm but potentially with a more regional feel (depending on office coverage and engagement team), Plante Moran remains a major player with significant 401(k) audit activity. Plan type coverage and service breadth When plan complexity goes beyond a 401(k) Both firms support the core retirement plan types—401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, and ESOP audits. A notable difference is that Baker Tilly also lists health & welfare plan support, which can matter if your organization wants one firm to cover multiple ERISA audits under one relationship. Baker Tilly: advisory, tax, and assurance with a “top ten” positioning and membership in Baker Tilly International (global network). Plante Moran: positions itself as one of the largest CPA and business advisory firms, offering audit, tax, investment banking, wealth management, and international consulting. Geography, staffing, and what it can mean for your engagement Baker Tilly lists a headquarters in Madison, Wisconsin and a workforce of 10,001 , signaling significant capacity for multi-location sponsors and tight audit timelines. Plante Moran’s employee count and HQ weren’t provided here, so buyers may want to confirm office locations, EBP team size, and who will staff the fieldwork (partner/manager continuity matters for recurring annual audits). How to decide between Baker Tilly and Plante Moran Choose Baker Tilly if you value very high 401(k) audit volume, broad ERISA coverage including health & welfare , and a large national/global network. Choose Plante Moran if you want a large, diversified advisory firm and your priority is a strong 401(k)/retirement plan audit provider with potentially more tailored team alignment based on office footprint and engagement structure. Next step: ask both firms for a proposal that details EBP-specific experience (your recordkeeper/custodian, plan features, ESOP/DB complexity), timeline , expected PBC list , and fee structure —since pricing wasn’t provided in the available data and can vary widely by participant count, number of payrolls, and plan design.