Baker Tilly vs Forvis Mazars

Compare Baker Tilly US LLP and Forvis Mazars, LLP side by side.

CategoryBaker Tilly US LLPForvis Mazars, LLP
Year Founded1,9312,003
Employees10,00140,000
HeadquartersMadison, WISpringfield, MO
Websitebakertilly.com/forvismazars.us/about-us
Latest Audit Statistics3,801 plans audited · $917.5B AUM2,714 plans audited · $423.6B AUM
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare401(k), 403(b), Defined Benefit, ESOP, Health & Welfare
AccreditationsAICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQCAICPA Member, AICPA EBPAQC
Published Pricing——
LocationsMadison, WISpringfield, MO, Springfield, MO

Comparison Details

Baker Tilly vs Forvis Mazars: choosing an auditor for your employee benefit plan Both Baker Tilly US LLP and Forvis Mazars, LLP are large, national-to-global accounting firms that provide employee benefit plan audits across common plan types, including 401(k) , 403(b) , defined benefit , ESOP , and health & welfare plans. If you’re selecting an audit firm for a retirement plan, the decision often comes down to (1) demonstrated benefit plan audit volume, (2) depth of specialized teams, (3) geographic coverage and service model, and (4) how the firm’s scale aligns with your sponsor’s complexity and expectations. At-a-glance comparison Headquarters: Baker Tilly (Madison, WI) vs Forvis Mazars (Springfield, MO) Founded: Baker Tilly (1931) vs Forvis Mazars (2003) Employees: Baker Tilly (~10,001) vs Forvis Mazars (~40,000) Plans supported: Both support 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit, ESOP, and health & welfare 401(k) audit footprint (2024): volume and plan assets audited One practical way to compare audit providers is to look at how many plans they audit and the amount of assets those audits cover. Based on the provided 2024 401(k) audit stats: Baker Tilly: 3,801 401(k) plans audited; $917.5B in audited 401(k) plan assets (AUM) Forvis Mazars: 2,714 401(k) plans audited; $423.6B in audited 401(k) plan assets (AUM) What this can mean for you: Baker Tilly’s higher 401(k) audit count and larger audited asset total may indicate a broader retirement plan audit footprint and frequent exposure to a wide range of plan sizes and operational scenarios. Forvis Mazars also shows significant volume and assets, which can be attractive if you want a large-firm platform with a strong audit-and-advisory bench. Firm profile and service model differences Baker Tilly US LLP Baker Tilly positions itself as a top-ten advisory, tax, and assurance firm with a “coast-to-coast and global advantage” through its membership in Baker Tilly International . Founded in 1931 , the firm emphasizes long-standing market presence and deep industry specialization . For plan sponsors, this can be a fit when you value established processes, mature quality controls, and teams that regularly coordinate across tax, assurance, and consulting disciplines. Forvis Mazars, LLP Forvis Mazars describes itself as a leading global provider of audit, tax, advisory, and consulting services, emphasizing an “ Unmatched Client Experience® .” With a larger stated employee base (~ 40,000 ) and a global orientation, Forvis Mazars may appeal to sponsors that want broad resources, multi-location support, or a firm experience geared toward structured client service and responsiveness across service lines. How to decide: best-fit scenarios Choose Baker Tilly if you prioritize a long-established firm (since 1931) and want an auditor with a higher reported 2024 401(k) audit count and larger audited asset footprint. Choose Forvis Mazars if you want a very large firm platform (higher employee count) with a global positioning and a client-experience-forward service message, while still maintaining substantial 401(k) audit volume. Key questions to ask either auditor before you sign Who will be on the engagement team, and how many employee benefit plan audits do they personally complete each year? What is the planned timeline for PBC requests, fieldwork, and report delivery? How does the firm handle common 401(k) risk areas (eligibility, deferrals, match, loans, distributions, and payroll interfaces)? Will you use specialists for ESOP, defined benefit, or health & welfare components if applicable? What drives fee variability (locations, participant count, investments, SOC reports, prior-year findings)? Ultimately, both Baker Tilly and Forvis Mazars are credible options for employee benefit plan audits. Use the audit footprint data as a starting point, then validate team specialization, communication cadence, and deliverables to find the best match for your plan’s complexity and your internal bandwidth.