ADP vs Paychex

Compare ADP Retirement Services and Paychex side by side.

CategoryADP Retirement ServicesPaychex
Year Founded1,9491,971
Employees—15,000
HeadquartersRoseland, NJRochester, NY
Websiteadp.com/what-we-offer/benefits/retirement.aspxpaychex.com/
Latest Client Statistics135,642 clients · $158.8B AUM124,000 clients · $55.7B AUM
Latest Audit Statistics——
Services3(16) Plan Administrator, 3(38) Investment Manager, Compliance Services, Participant Investment Advice, Plan Design Consulting, Recordkeeping3(16) Plan Administrator, Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, 3(21) Investment Advisor, 3(38) Investment Manager
Plans Supported401(k), 403(b)401(k)
AccreditationsOther—
Published PricingStandard: $325 base fee, $5/employee, $3,000 setup fee—
LocationsFlorham Park, NJ, Roseland, NJ, Florham Park, NJRochester, NY

Comparison Details

ADP vs Paychex: Which retirement plan administrator fits your business? Choosing between ADP Retirement Services and Paychex often comes down to how much fiduciary help you want, what plan types you need, and whether transparent pricing is important. Both providers are well-known for serving employers alongside payroll and HR needs, but their retirement administration capabilities differ in meaningful ways. Company background and scale ADP Retirement Services (founded 1949, HQ: Roseland, NJ) is part of ADP, one of the largest business services providers in the U.S. ADP positions its retirement offering as a comprehensive solution with administration, investments support, and participant education. Paychex (founded 1971, HQ: Rochester, NY; ~15,000 employees) is a major payroll and HR platform with retirement services. Available plan data indicates substantial retirement scale: 124,000 401(k) clients, about $55.7B in AUM, and roughly 1,608,060 participants (2025). Plan types supported ADP : Supports 401(k) and 403(b) plans—useful if you’re a nonprofit or education-focused organization needing 403(b) administration. Paychex : Listed support includes 401(k) . If you need a 403(b), you’ll want to confirm availability and service scope directly. Services and fiduciary capabilities This is one of the biggest differences for sponsors comparing ADP vs Paychex. ADP offers a broader set of retirement plan services, including recordkeeping , plan design , compliance support , participant advice , and fiduciary services such as 3(16) administrative fiduciary support and 3(38) investment fiduciary management. For employers seeking to offload day-to-day administrative duties and/or investment decision responsibility, these designations can be a key differentiator. Paychex is listed here with recordkeeping . If you’re primarily looking for a payroll-linked recordkeeping solution and prefer to keep fiduciary responsibilities with an internal committee or external advisor, this may align well—but confirm whether additional fiduciary or compliance services are available in your specific package. Pricing transparency and expected costs Published pricing is available for ADP in this dataset, while Paychex pricing is not provided—so the comparison hinges on transparency. ADP pricing (Standard) : $325 base fee, $5 per employee, and a $3,000 setup fee. This structure can be easier to model for budgeting, especially for small and mid-sized plans that want predictable admin costs. Paychex pricing : Not listed here. Paychex retirement pricing commonly depends on plan design, participant counts, and bundled payroll/HR selections, so you’ll typically need a custom quote. Which is better for your plan? Choose ADP Retirement Services if you want 403(b) support , need 3(16) and/or 3(38) fiduciary services, value a more full-service administration approach, or prefer clear baseline pricing to start your evaluation. Choose Paychex if your priority is a 401(k) solution tied closely to a major payroll/HR provider and you want a platform with demonstrated large-scale adoption (124,000 plans and 1.6M+ participants in 2025), while being comfortable requesting a tailored quote for total costs. Next step: request a proposal from each provider that itemizes recordkeeping fees , setup costs , per-participant charges , and any fiduciary services (3(16)/3(38)) so you can compare total plan cost and sponsor workload side-by-side.