| Category | ADP Retirement Services | Guideline, Inc. |
|---|---|---|
| Year Founded | 1,949 | 2,015 |
| Employees | — | 350 |
| Headquarters | Roseland, NJ | Burlingame, CA |
| Website | adp.com/what-we-offer/benefits/retirement.aspx | guideline.com/ |
| Latest Client Statistics | 135,642 clients · $158.8B AUM | 60,000 clients · $15.0B AUM |
| Services | 3(16) Plan Administrator, 3(38) Investment Manager, Compliance Services, Participant Investment Advice, Plan Design Consulting, Recordkeeping | Fiduciary Audit Services, Plan Design Consulting, 3(16) Plan Administrator, Recordkeeping, Compliance Services, Participant Investment Advice, 3(38) Investment Manager |
| Plans Supported | 401(k), 403(b) | 401(k), Solo 401(k), SEP IRA |
| Accreditations | Other | — |
| Published Pricing | Standard: $325 base fee, $5/employee, $3,000 setup fee | Core: $89 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Enterprise: $149 base fee, $8/employee, $0 setup fee Starter: $39 base fee, $4/employee, $0 setup fee |
| Locations | Florham Park, NJ, Roseland, NJ, Florham Park, NJ | Burlingame, CA |
Comparison Details
ADP vs Guideline: Which 401(k) Administrator Fits Your Business? Choosing between ADP Retirement Services and Guideline, Inc. often comes down to how you want to run your retirement plan: a large, established benefits platform tied closely to payroll/HR (ADP) versus a modern, technology-first 401(k) administrator designed for streamlined setup and ongoing management (Guideline). Both support core retirement plan administration functions like compliance, recordkeeping, plan design, and participant support—yet they differ meaningfully in pricing structure, target customer, and platform experience. Company profile and market focus ADP Retirement Services (founded 1949; HQ: Roseland, NJ) is part of ADP, one of the most recognized names in payroll and HR. It’s typically a fit for employers who want retirement services connected to a broader HR ecosystem and established operational infrastructure. Guideline (founded 2015; ~350 employees; HQ: Burlingame, CA) is a fintech retirement provider built around automation and a clean employer/participant experience. It is widely adopted among small and midsize businesses seeking a simple, scalable 401(k) rollout. Plans supported: 401(k) and beyond ADP supports 401(k) and 403(b) , which can matter for certain nonprofit and education-adjacent employers evaluating provider options. Guideline supports 401(k) , solo 401(k) , and SEP IRA , giving more flexibility for owner-only businesses and very small employers that may not be ready for a full traditional plan. Fiduciary services and administration capabilities Both providers list key fiduciary and operational services that many employers look for when comparing a 401(k) administrator: 3(16) administration (helps offload certain day-to-day plan administrative responsibilities) 3(38) investment fiduciary (delegated investment management responsibility) Compliance , plan design , recordkeeping , and participant advice Where they often differ is delivery: ADP tends to appeal to employers who want a traditional provider model with broad service depth, while Guideline emphasizes a software-led workflow and integrated experience (including payroll synchronization), which can reduce manual tasks for lean HR teams. Pricing comparison: ADP vs Guideline Cost is one of the clearest differentiators on this comparison page. ADP pricing (Standard) : $325/month base fee + $5 per employee/month + $3,000 setup fee . Guideline pricing (no setup fee): Starter : $39/month + $4 per employee/month Core : $89/month + $8 per employee/month Enterprise : $149/month + $8 per employee/month In many scenarios, Guideline’s zero setup fee and low base pricing can be attractive for startups and small businesses. ADP’s higher upfront setup fee may be easier to justify for organizations that value a long-established provider and want retirement plan services aligned with a broader ADP HR/payroll environment. Scale and traction Guideline reports significant platform scale, including approximately 60,000 401(k) clients, $15B in AUM, and roughly 500,000 participants (reported for 2026). ADP is a legacy provider within a large public company, which may appeal to employers prioritizing vendor longevity and enterprise-grade operations. Which provider is better for your plan? Choose ADP Retirement Services if you want support for 403(b) , prefer a long-tenured provider, and value retirement administration that can align with ADP’s broader payroll/HR capabilities. Choose Guideline if you want transparent, low entry pricing , no setup fee , and a technology-first experience with streamlined administration for a growing business (including options like solo 401(k) and SEP IRA ). Ultimately, the best administrator depends on your plan type, headcount, payroll environment, and how much you want to outsource fiduciary responsibilities through 3(16) and 3(38) services. Comparing total costs (including setup), plan flexibility, and the day-to-day workflow is the fastest way to decide between ADP vs Guideline.